Rocky start for Alabama school choice bill

A glass door opens to an empty senate chamber. A blue circular seal on the door shows a design of a book, a torch and the state of Alabama with the text "Alabama State Senate."

A door opens to the senate chamber at the Alabama State House on March 7, 2023.

Mary Scott Hodgin, WBHM

Republican lawmakers in Alabama held their first committee meeting this week on a school choice bill which would give families $6,900 in taxpayer money​ through an education saving account to be used for private school or homeschooling. The bill faced significant criticism.

“It wasn’t a tremendously favorable reception for sponsors of the bill,” said Todd Stacy, host of Capitol Journal on Alabama Public Television.

Stacy discussed that and other action in the legislature this week.

Choosey on choice

The bill is very broad, in part, because there are no income restrictions. Families who currently have children in private school or home school are eligible. Proponents said parents are in the best position to choose the education option that’s best for their children but Stacy said the big hangup for members of the Senate Education Policy Committee Wednesday was accountability.

“There aren’t the kind of guardrails with accountability that other states have passed in their similar school choice laws,” Stacy said.

Lawmakers questioned the lack of a testing requirement or other mechanism that could assess how students using the education savings accounts were performing academically.

“A lot of folks in the education space and the legislature, they’ve been working hard over the last several years to bring up Alabama’s scores. This doesn’t go in line with that,” Stacy said. “I would say a majority of this committee are for school choice the concept … but there are particulars of this bill that make it problematic.”

Following the public hearing, the committee chairman announced the bill would move to the Senate education budget committee because of the budget impact. The Legislative Services Agency estimated it could cost the education budget $576.1 million if 5% of eligible public school students participated.

Meanwhile, the House Education Budget Committee took up a narrower school choice bill called the SUN Act or Students with Unique Needs. This bill would also use education savings accounts but offer only $5,600 in taxpayer money and limit participation to 500 students. Students must also have a parent in the military, are in the foster care system or meet other specific criteria. 

“For that reason I actually think this is going to move in the legislature,” Stacy said. “For those who want the broader school choice, the whole hog proposal, this could be a starting point.”

Step one for the General Fund

On Tuesday, the House unanimously passed a General Fund budget of more than $3 billion, backed by flush tax receipts. The budget is about $15 more than what Gov. Kay Ivey proposed.

“The only reason for that is that they see revenue projections going even higher just in these couple of months that have passed,” Stacy said.

Essentially all non-education state agencies would receive funding increases under the spending plan, with notable bumps for the Department of Mental Health and Department of Public Health. State employees would see a 2% pay raise. The bill now goes to the Senate.

Harsher penalties for retail theft

Alabama retailers and district attorneys have said theft is becoming a major problem.

“In fact causing stores to either close down or consider closing down, which is a real problem especially in places that are lacking options to begin with,” Stacy said. “They say the state [and] prosecutors need better tools to crack down.”

House and Senate committee heard a pair of bills this week which would increase penalties for those convicted of theft regardless of the amount that is stolen. Proponents say current law means those individuals often skip time behind bars. Opponents expressed concern about how broadly the bill would apply, particularly with no minimum for the value of the item taken.

The bill also creates a new crime of organized theft. 

“They’re saying what’s going on isn’t just petty [theft], but organized folks are going and stealing certain items in a group and then selling those items,” Stacy said.

A Senate version of the bill passed committee while the House version stalled.

Other action

House Judiciary Committee approves stripped-down parole bill

Alabama senators back bill to cut state sales tax on food

Includes reporting from the Associated Press  


Alabama’s prison population sees troubling growth in latest DOJ report

For the first time in nearly a decade, U.S. prison populations are trending up. Alabama's numbers are a part of troubling gains across the Gulf South.

A narrowing Republican presidential field will debate in Tuscaloosa Wednesday

Four candidates will be on stage at the University of Alabama for their last scheduled meeting before the Iowa caucuses kick off the presidential nominating season next month. Former President Donald Trump, the race’s clear front-runner, will not be among them.

Place, Erased: A virtual listening session with the Gulf States Newsroom; RSVP now

Join us as we listen to the recent series about towns transformed by major environmental shifts and talk with the reporters about what they learned.

Tuberville is ending blockade of most military nominees

Tuberville’s blockade of military promotions was over a dispute about a Pentagon abortion policy. The Alabama Republican said Tuesday he’s “not going to hold the promotions of these people any longer.”

Man featured in ‘S-Town’ podcast shot and killed by police during standoff, authorities say

Joseph Tyler Goodson was shot by officers after he barricaded himself inside a home and “brandished a gun" at officers early Sunday, the Alabama Law Enforcement Agency said. Bibb County Coroner Patrick Turner said that Goodson was pronounced “brain dead” Tuesday night at a hospital.

The next Republican debate is in Alabama, the state that gave the GOP a road map to Donald Trump

The state that propelled George Wallace, a Democrat and four-term governor, into national politics is now dominated by Republicans loyal to Donald Trump, another figure who leans heavily on grievance and white identity politics.

More 2023 Alabama Legislative Session Coverage