Police identify the victims from Thursday’s deadly church shooting in Vestavia Hills

Captain Shane Ware address press on Friday, June 17, 2022.

Captain Shane Ware address press on Friday, June 17, 2022.

Miranda Fulmore, WBHM

1:46 PM UPDATE: The third victim, an 84-year-old white female from Hoover, has died, according to the Vestavia Hills Police Department.

Authorities with the Vestavia Hills Police Department identified the victims as 84-year-old Walter Rainey, of Irondale, and 75-year-old Sarah Yeager, of Pelham. An 84-year-old white female from Hoover remains hospitalized.

The shooting happened just before sundown Thursday night at St. Stephen’s Episcopal Church in the Cahaba Heights neighborhood of Vestavia.

Police Captain Shane Ware identified the suspect as a 71-year-old white male who occasionally attended the church. They haven’t released a motive but said he used a handgun.

Another church attendee held the man down until police arrived, according to police.

“It was extremely critical in saving lives. The person that subdued the suspect – in my opinion – is a hero,” said Capt. Ware.

Two members of Saint Stevens Episcopal Church hug after a shooting at the church killed two and injured one.
Church members console each other after a shooting at the Saint Stevens Episcopal Church on Thursday, June 16, 2022 in Vestavia, Ala.

The suspect remains in police custody. Ware said they’ll likely release the man’s name after the capital murder warrants are signed by the Jefferson County District Attorney’s Office.

Across town in nearby Mountain Brook, community members gathered Friday morning for a service at Saint Luke’s Episcopal Church. They prayed, sang, heard readings from the Bible, and recited Psalm 23.

“We are so sad and so angry and so shocked and so disappointed in so many things and so disoriented,” said the Rt. Rev. Dr. Glenda Curry, bishop of the Episcopal Diocese of Alabama. “But God is with us and only God’s love can heal us like we need to be healed.”

Curry told those gathered to surround the victims’ families and the Saint Stephens congregation with prayers and love “for as long as they need us.”

She noted she had received many messages of encouragement from Episcopal churches from around the world.

“We believe that God is working with us in this terrible horror and that God will never stop working to make all things new,” Curry said

Andrew Yeager and Kyra Miles contributed to this story.


Despite pushback, the organizers of Cullman’s first PRIDE event are pushing forward

The announcement of Saturday’s event drew threats and calls for counter-protests. In response, LGBTQ+ communities across the state have offered their support.

6 ways the conversation around a guaranteed income in the US has changed

A guaranteed income conference held in Atlanta shows how the movement has progressed since 2017, with more than 50 pilots currently handing out cash.

New mental health crisis center aims to interrupt revolving door of jail and ER visits

The new clinic in Jefferson County will offer short-term crisis care to people who might otherwise wait hours at a hospital or wind up in jail.

Mississippi’s latest move in its anti-abortion agenda? A tax break for corporate donations

Tax documents show energy company foundations financed the anti-abortion movement in the Gulf South for years. Now, they could get a tax break for that support.

Birmingham City Council moves toward approval of cannabis dispensaries

Birmingham has taken “the first step” on the road to legalizing medical marijuana. The City Council voted Tuesday to approve an ordinance authorizing medical cannabis dispensaries to operate within Birmingham city limits.

The landmark Voting Rights Act faces further dismantling in case from Alabama

The law is once again on the chopping block ­— this time on the question of how state legislatures may draw congressional district lines when the state's voters are racially polarized.

More Crime Coverage