Midwives urge Alabama health officials to revise rules on birth centers


Deborah Harris, a registered nurse and doula, speaks during a public hearing about the ADPH proposed rules on birth centers.

Alabama Birth Coalition

Maternal health advocates across Alabama are speaking out about possible new regulations to license birth centers. 

“It’s clear that whoever reviewed these (proposed rules) did not understand current obstetric practice,” said Sharon Holley, a doctor of nursing practice (DNP), certified professional midwife (CPM) and registered nurse (RN) who directs UAB’s Nurse-Midwifery program.

Holley and others voiced their concerns during a public hearing on August 18. 

The event, hosted by the Alabama Department of Public Health (ADPH), drew roughly 90 people, including midwives, doctors and nurses. 

Critics said the rules, proposed by the ADPH, are too restrictive and do not align with evidence-based best practices and national standards in operating birth centers. 

“I have compiled a list of over 70 changes needed in the first 20 pages of this 48-page proposed document,” said Nancy Megginson, a CPM and RN based in Tuscaloosa.

According to the American Association of Birth Centers, a birth center is a freestanding “home-like” facility where people can give birth outside of a hospital under the care of licensed midwives and health care providers.

Alabama used to have rules governing birth centers, but because there were no birth centers in the state, the rules were repealed in 2010 in an effort to cut red tape. 

According to the AABC, Alabama is one of a handful of states with no regulations governing birth centers.

There are still no birth centers actively operating in Alabama, but several providers plan to soon open facilities in Huntsville, Gainesville, and Birmingham.

That prompted state health officials to re-establish licensure requirements. 

“Under Alabama law, no one may establish, conduct or maintain such facilities without first obtaining a license from ADPH,” officials said in an email. “In light of the announced intent to establish new birthing centers, the regulations are needed.”

A key issue with the proposed rules is that they do not authorize certified professional midwives to work in birth centers. 

Birth advocates said that contradicts Alabama law, which states that “a licensed midwife may provide midwifery care in the setting of the client’s choice, except a hospital.” 

“This is our lane. This is what we do” said Stephanie Mitchell, CPM and DNP.

Mitchell is preparing to open one of the state’s first birthing centers in Gainesville, a town of a few hundred people in Sumter County. 

She said her birth center won’t be able to open if ADPH officials approve the proposed rules, further limiting access to care.  

“If you look at what we’re talking about here in terms of health care accessibility, we are what people term a health care desert,” Mitchell said. “There are not any physicians in this space.”

Mitchell and other birthing advocates agree that the state needs to reinstate regulations, but they want ADPH officials to collaborate with midwives. 

“Let’s revisit,” said Holley during last week’s public hearing. “Let’s form a committee of the people who are the stakeholders, who know this work and who can help provide good guidance for what is needed in this state.” 

ADPH officials declined an interview request for this story. 

In an email, officials said they will “thoroughly consider” all feedback and will either adopt the rules as proposed, make changes based on the comments or determine not to adopt the rules. 

The public can submit comments on the proposed rules until 5 p.m. on Friday, September 2.


Jefferson County drug overdose deaths hit new peak in 2022

Drug overdose deaths topped gun and vehicle-related deaths investigated last year by the Jefferson County Coroner’s Office.

‘Nobody is getting to you’: How workforce challenges leave Gulf South EMS agencies strapped

Emergency services in Louisiana are spending more time waiting to offload patients at hospitals and that means fewer are responding to calls at any given time.

Presence of chemicals in landfill fire smoke catalyzes EPA to step in

The EPA is taking action to extinguish the fire after air sampling results showed carcinogenic chemicals in smoke from the site.

Birmingham-Southern president says he’ll do everything possible to keep the college open

Birmingham-Southern College, a private institution, is asking the state to help bail it out after financial troubles. School President Daniel Coleman shared with WBHM what he sees as the path ahead for the college.

Alabama extends time for executions, ends automatic review

The Alabama Supreme Court abolished the one-day time frame for executions. Instead, the governor will set a window of time. The court also eliminated an automatic “plain error review” of death penalty cases.

Parole denied for 90% of Alabama inmates, a new low

The rate of state inmates being granted parole in Alabama has plummeted to a new low, with 90% of eligible inmates being rejected last fiscal year.

More Front Page Coverage