Bill advances which would further protect police from criminal, civil prosecution
A recent bill in Alabama’s legislature would establish new legal protections for police officers who use physical or deadly force on a person while in the line of duty. Bill supporters say it will improve police safety, recruitment and retention. But critics worry it would give police officers immunity from criminal prosecution.
Current law protects officers from liability for their actions unless they act willfully, maliciously, fraudulently, in bad faith, beyond their authority or under mistaken interpretation of the law.
HB 202, however, would protect officers from criminal prosecution when they use physical force. This protection lasts so long as they act within their “discretionary authority” and do not violate a person’s constitutional right to not have excessive force inflicted on them.
“Just as much as additional protections are in this bill, it also clearly lays out when an officer acts outside that discretionary authority in a reckless manner,” the bill’s sponsor, Republican Rep. Rex Reynolds, said. “Then all the civil and criminal prosecutions stay in place.”
The bill protects against civil liability if officers act recklessly. If an officer is charged, Reynolds said there will be a pretrial hearing within 45 days in which a judge will decide if the officer’s actions were within the scope of their work. Under the bill, protections extend to corrections officers.
The bill is part of a larger package of bills aimed at fighting crime. Reynolds added police departments have been struggling to adequately recruit officers.
“I think law enforcement [has been] under scrutiny over the last 5 or 6 years in states, not just Alabama but across the country, has kind of created that environment,” Reynolds said. “This is about showing Alabama law enforcement that we support them. We’re standing behind them.”
But bill opponents are concerned the measure will protect police officers when they should be prosecuted.
“This bill will further prevent police from being able to be prosecuted because they can say, ‘I was doing this either to protect myself’ or ‘because I felt threatened,’ if it’s more deadly force,” Benard Simelton, president of the Alabama chapter of the NAACP, said.
Simelton added that police already have extensive immunity from prosecution. He argued it is already too difficult to bring charges against an officer over misconduct.
“Why do they need additional protection?” Simelton said. “They already have enough protection under the color of law.”
During a House committee hearing Wednesday, Reynolds debated Democratic Rep. Christopher England over the language of the bill.
England pointed out that current law gives both police and civilians the right to a “stand your ground” hearing in criminal cases, in which a judge looks at the facts of the case and decides if the defendant acted in self-defense. But under HB202, England argued that police officers would have a special, legal defense based on their status as an officer rather than the facts of the situation at hand.
The bill passed out of committee and now heads to the full House.
4 astronauts splashdown on SpaceX capsule to end Axiom Space’s private Ax-4 mission
The private crew included Ax-4 mission commander and former NASA astronaut Peggy Whitson. It was her fifth trip to space and extended her record-setting duration to 695 days, the most of any American.
Heavy rains and flash flooding sweep across Northeast
Flash flood watches and warnings were in place in parts of New Jersey, New York, Pennsylvania and surrounding areas as downpours moved through the region.
Will Congress cut funds to NPR/PBS and foreign aid this week?
The Trump Administration has asked Congress to rescind funds for NPR/PBS and Foreign aid. Congress has until the end of the week to approve the cuts.
Power prices are expected to soar under new tax cut and spending law
In states without policies to drive renewable energy, power prices could surge as federal tax incentives for clean energy disappear, according to Energy Innovation, a think tank.
This family wants to have more babies, but not in a hospital
The Trump administration is encouraging people to have more children, with baby bonuses and tax breaks. But some families who are practicing pronatalism want alternatives to hospital births.
Republicans renew a bid to remove noncitizens from the census tally behind voting maps
GOP lawmakers are trying again to exclude millions of non-U.S. citizens living in the states from census counts that the 14th Amendment says must include the "whole number of persons in each state."