‘Warfare’ embeds the audience in the chaos of modern combat

In his 2024 action-drama, Civil War, the British director Alex Garland imagined a dystopian America torn apart by violence. For all its echoes of the present day, I found the movie politically neutral to the point of vagueness, and I couldn’t buy into its world building. I did, however, buy into its world destroying, which is to say, its viscerally terrifying action sequences. In staging the battle scenes, Garland worked closely with a military adviser, Ray Mendoza, a former U.S. Navy SEAL who’s also lent his expertise to the war drama Lone Survivor and the video game, Call of Duty: Modern Warfare.

Now Garland and Mendoza have reteamed on a new movie, simply titled Warfare. The two co-wrote and co-directed the film, which reconstructs an incident from the Iraq War, in November 2006, when a routine mission by Mendoza and his fellow SEALs went dangerously awry. The script was drawn entirely from Mendoza’s and his comrades’ memories, with no attempt to fill in the war’s broader context. The aim is to embed the audience with the soldiers and provide as immersive an experience of modern combat as possible.

It begins at night, when a squad of SEALs break into a two-story apartment building in the city of Ramadi, known to be a hotbed of Al Qaeda insurgency. By the next morning, they’ve set up a surveillance operation, but the details of their mission remain unclear, which only ratchets up the tension. There’s no exposition, only terse, often-indecipherable bursts of military jargon.

The SEALs are played by actors including Will Poulter, Joseph Quinn, Michael Gandolfini and, as the young Mendoza himself, D’Pharaoh Woon-A-Tai, from the series Reservation Dogs. But we barely get to know their characters’ names or backgrounds. They don’t crack jokes or tell stories from back home; they haven’t been given the cliché of one distinguishing personality trait apiece. Most of the time, we see and hear them functioning as a unit, and a cohesive, very well-trained one.

The SEALs mostly sit quietly in wait; one sniper, Elliott, played by Cosmo Jarvis, keeps his rifle trained on a house across the street, where he suspects insurgents are hiding. And then all hell breaks loose: An unseen enemy drops a grenade into the building, making it clear that their presence has been discovered.

Given how many films we’ve seen about U.S. troops in combat, from Platoon and Full Metal Jacket to Saving Private Ryan and The Hurt Locker, it’s a tall order for a movie to say something new about the experience. But Warfare succeeds, in part, by committing to a level of moment-to-moment realism that those earlier films, even at their most harrowing, didn’t strive for.

Most of the story plays out in real time, and as the SEALs wait and wait for armored vehicles to bring them to safety, the directors aren’t afraid to slow the pace down and draw things out to an agonizing degree. The movie’s second half is at once excruciating and mesmerizing; an IED goes off, casualties are sustained, and wounds are lingered on at graphic length. You’re reminded of how quickly some war movies cut away from the carnage, but Warfare doesn’t; some of its soldiers’ anguished screams are still echoing in my brain.

Some will find Garland and Mendoza’s film too narrowly focused, to the exclusion of any deeper insight into the war. Similar critiques were leveled at The Hurt Locker, still perhaps the best American drama ever made about the Iraq War, and they’re no more convincing when lobbed at Warfare. Those looking for politics will find it, I think, in the way Garland and Mendoza avoid jingoism and false heroics; there are acts of heroism here, to be sure, but no glorification.

And we’re never allowed to forget that the American soldiers are a hostile, intrusive presence. From time to time, we see Iraqi civilian families huddling in terror in the apartment building where the SEALs have set up their operation. There are also quick glimpses of insurgents firing from rooftops across the street. At times I wondered what kind of movie could be made about the same events from their perspective, with the same radical absence of cliché. Warfare doesn’t just offer a corrective to the war movies we’ve seen already; it’s powerful enough to leave us thinking about all the ones we still have yet to see.

 

DHS ends Temporary Protected Status for thousands from Nicaragua and Honduras

Some 76,000 people from Nicaragua and Honduras were covered by TPS, which provides protection from deportation and grants work permits to people from certain nations affected by war or natural disasters.

DOJ says no evidence Jeffrey Epstein had a ‘client list’ or blackmailed associates

The two-page memo outlines the "exhaustive review" the department conducted of the Epstein files in its possession, and also reiterates that Epstein died by suicide, contrary to some conspiracy theories.

Floods are getting more dangerous around the country, not just in Texas

The deadly floods in Central Texas were caused by extremely heavy rain. Climate change is causing even more rain to fall during the heaviest storms.

Near old Montana mine, special clinic for asbestos-related illness fights to survive

The Center for Asbestos Related Disease in Libby, Montana, closed in May after a court judgment. The clinic's federal funding is also threatened. Patients with scarred lungs worry about what's next.

4 things to know about the deadly Texas floods and ongoing search efforts

Search efforts continue for the dozens of people still missing after Friday's floods, as questions swirl over what went wrong. Here's what we know so far.

In Peru, criminal gangs are targeting schools in poor neighborhoods for extortion

The president of one of Lima's largest parent-teacher associations says at least 1,000 schools in the Peruvian capital are being extorted and that most are caving into the demands of the gangs.

More Front Page Coverage