Researcher Finds Emojis Still Lack Diversity
It’s World Emoji Day. Those little characters that help users express themselves online first appeared in the U.S. in 2011. About five years ago, Unicode, the organization responsible for emojis, added skin tone modifiers in an effort to be more diverse. Miriam Sweeney is an assistant professor in the School of Library and Information Studies at the University of Alabama. In a study published last year, Sweeney found that emojis continue to center around whiteness even with characters that seem inclusive.
Is technology race-less?
I think we take for granted the technologies that we use every day and often these technologies also want us to, I think, blend into the background and purport themselves to be neutral or race-less in these different ways. But they’re not. They’re part of the built environment representing a lot of human choices and decision making, and that’s always happening in a cultural context. And in this case, what I wanted to focus on was the way that racial ideologies or beliefs about race were influencing the design of these technologies.
How are emojis still centered around whiteness after adding diverse characters?
So part of what I was looking at was the way that whiteness was designed as kind of the center organizing schema of emojis when they rolled out. And that’s where users were identifying that there’s some racial bias happening there. But rather than rethinking that whole schema, we got these sort of add-ons — this kind of additive structure that provides more race options. And that was great in the sense that it did give more access to diverse representations of race. And also, at the same time, we went from having just men emoji doctors to women and men emoji doctors. So they expanded in a lot of different ways. But in some sense, the base decisions remain central. For instance, several black users noted that the emojis now have a different skin color, but they still retain these kind of European phenotypic features, so the same smooth hair and facial structures as before. So it’s a case where the representation did shift and become broader. But at the center, that base character remains the same. We didn’t rethink that original image and representation.
How can the issue of race be solved within this technology?
So, first of all, I think that Unicode itself has thought of it as a race problem to solve, which is sort of interesting. So the approach that they have taken is every year there’s a panel of representatives and anyone can propose new emojis and try to make a case for why this representation should be added in. And each year we see the results of that. We see expanded representations and it’s like a never ending task to represent all of the different cultural specificities in the diverse world. So they can, in a sense, never really catch up. They’ve kind of started with a central base and now this model where they’re adding on new representations all the time is an endless model.
This interview has been condensed and edited for clarity.
Here are some of the NPR stories that had a big impact in 2024
From learning a new skill to prompting federal legislation, here are some of the ways people's lives were affected by the NPR Network's journalism this year.
50 wonderful things from 2024
Pop culture critic Linda Holmes has been making this annual list since 2010. Big, small, inspirational, silly — what these items have in common is that they are all wonderful and brought her joy.
The 2024 moments that will stick with us: Reflections from the Gulf States Newsroom
Our regional reporters reflect on delightful, discarded moments they had in the field as they covered stories across Alabama, Mississippi and Louisiana.
Israeli strike kills 5 Palestinian journalists in Gaza, officials say
An Israeli strike killed five Palestinian journalists outside a hospital in the Gaza Strip overnight, according to the Health Ministry. The Israeli military said it had targeted a group of militants.
Minn. Democratic party chair says his wins could help nationally after loss to Trump
Ken Martin helped turn around the Minnesota Democratic-Farmer-Labor Party's finances and secure a streak of statewide wins for the party over 18 years. Now, he wants to do the same thing for the Democratic National Committee.
Giving up alcohol for Dry January? Our newsletter can help you reach your goal
If your New Year's resolution is to drink less alcohol, Life Kit is here to help. Sign up for our Dry January newsletter series, and get tips and strategies to help you stay alcohol-free for a month.
