Civil Rights Institute Reverses Decision on Angela Davis Award Again

1548414889, Flickr

The Birmingham Civil Rights Institute will award Birmingham native Angela Davis its 2018 Fred Shuttlesworth Human Rights Award — again. Friday’s reversal is the latest development in a public controversy that has embroiled the institute for the last month.

BCRI officials announced in October Davis would receive the annual award. But on January 3rd, the board voted at a special meeting to rescind the award saying Davis did not “meet all of the criteria on which the award is based.” The statement did not specify any criteria.

Davis grew up in Birmingham during the civil rights era. The longtime civil rights activist is former a member of the Black Panther and Communist parties. She’s a retired professor of the University of California, Santa Cruz. Davis is also a vocal critic of the Israeli government’s policies toward Palestinians and supports the movement to boycott Israel.

That support appears to have motivated the decision to rescind the award. Birmingham Mayor Randall Woodfin, an ex-officio member of the BCRI board, said in a statement at the time the decision was made “after protests from some members of the community, Jewish and otherwise.” Days before the award was rescinded, the Birmingham Holocaust Education Center’s board wrote the BCRI  saying they were concerned and disappointed with the decision to honor Davis.

The board’s move prompted a wave of criticism. Woodfin said he was “dismayed.” Activists called for board members to resignThree board member did resign and the board issued an apology a few days later. Davis said she would still come to Birmingham in February, despite the gala honoring her having been cancelled, for a series of alternative events.

Friday’s statement from the BCRI board says the board voted January 14th, the day it issued the apology, to “reaffirm Dr. Davis as the recipient.” It says the board immediately invited Davis to reaccept the award. The statement says the vote was part of learning from its mistakes and keeping in line with the organization’s mission.

Interim board chair Rev. Thomas Wilder says the reversal is a matter of conscience.

“Public repentance can be very, very difficult and very brutal,” Wilder says. “But if you really want to stand by what you think is right, then you do that and you deal with whatever consequences come.”

Wilder says the handling of the award was not meant to embarrass Davis and he hopes she does accept it. But he says he accepts whatever decision she makes.

“She has been publicly humiliated in her own hometown and sometimes that takes a little time to work through,” Wilder says.

Calls to the Birmingham Holocaust Education Center and Angela Davis were not immediately returned.

Updated Friday at 1:45 p.m. to add quotes from Wilder.

Photo by

More Birmingham Civil Rights Institute Coverage

BCRI Board Gets 12 New Members, 5 Reappointed

The Birmingham Civil Rights Institute Board received a makeover Tuesday with the City Council’s appointment of a dozen new members and reappointment of five current members.

A Friendly Homecoming for Activist Angela Davis

Civil rights activist and Birmingham native Angela Davis spoke at Birmingham's Boutwell Auditorium Saturday evening. The talk came after a controversy over an award from the Birmingham Civil Rights Institute.

Civil Rights Institute Grapples With Fallout From Davis Decision

A few weeks from now, political activist Angela Davis is expected to speak in Birmingham. This despite that earlier this month, the Birmingham Civil Rights Institute rescinded an award it initially planned to give to Davis. The decision roiled the city, sowed divisions, and led to the resignation of three board members.

Civil Rights Institute Apologizes as Questions Remain

The Birmingham Civil Rights Institute apologized today (Monday) for the way it has handled the Reverend Fred L. Shuttlesworth Human Rights Award and the impact of cancelling the award presentation to human rights activist Angela Davis.

Birmingham Civil Rights Institute Board Leaders Resign Over Award Controversy

Board leaders for the Birmingham Civil Rights Institute stepped down today following days of controversy over a decision to cancel a prestigious award presentation to noted scholar and activist Angela Davis.

Alternative Events Planned To Recognize Birmingham Native Angela Davis

More developments came today in response to the Birmingham Civil Rights Institute's decision to cancel an award presentation for scholar and activist Angela Davis. The top three leaders on the Institute’s board resigned and another group announced alternative events to honor the Birmingham native.

More Birmingham Civil Rights Institute Coverage