“The Edge of the Woods”: UAB Epidemiologist Says Herd Immunity Could Be Reached By Late Spring
An epidemiologist at UAB Medicine thinks that Alabama may be headed toward a long-sought goal in the COVID pandemic and may reach that goal sooner than many had expected.
Dr. Suzanne Judd said in a press conference Wednesday that the state is getting closer to herd immunity, a state where the virus stops its spread because a large part of the population is immune, either through vaccination or by because they have antibodies in their systems because of previous infections — in many cases, infections people didn’t even realize they had.
Judd cited a study by Columbia University which showed that there were up to 10 times as many people who were infected and developed antibodies than had tested positive for COVID. Most of this occurred in the New York City area early in the pandemic, when testing was not readily available, and many people were infected but showed mild symptoms or none at all.
Tests conducted at UAB show a ratio closer to 5-to-1. Coupling that with the current rate of vaccination, she said that Alabama could reach herd immunity as early as late summer.
“The more people that have immunity, the less the virus will spread and the safer it will be for us to interact with one another again,” Judd said. “But there’s no magical number that is herd immunity. Each virus, each bacteria is different and they mutate at regular intervals, so this number can move. But at the moment, scientists are shooting for about 72% of the population with immunity.”
Judd said the level is likely to be reached by late May or early June in Alabama, depending on many factors.
“It depends on the rate of vaccination, it depends on how many people actually have antibodies or immunities who didn’t have a positive test, and it depends on whether or not the virus mutates in the next few months,” Judd said. “So we’re going to keep looking at those numbers, but overall it’s looking exciting that we might start to see these higher levels of immunity in the late spring or early summer.”
The timeline may be greatly affected by any COVID-19 variants that show up later and whether current vaccines are effective against the variants or if booster shots may be required.
The Centers for Disease Control has already established a network to keep tabs on seasonal flu variants and has since expanded to add a similar network for COVID.
“The variants are something we have to watch very carefully. That said, it’s something we do all the time with flu,” Judd said.
Judd’s conclusion assumes that 50,000 Alabamians will receive their second dose of the two current vaccines each week, a level she described as “quite low” compared to the current rate. To be conservative and make sure restrictions are not loosened too soon, Judd used a 3-to-1 untested immunity ratio assumption in her research.
“If we scale up and those vaccines come online faster, that just means we could reach herd immunity a little bit sooner,” she said, adding that applying the 3-to-1 ratio against 500,000 positive tests so far, more than 1.5 million people in the state could have developed antibodies without knowing they had been infected.
Judd emphasized that there’s no magic number that would mark the end of the virus spread or allow public events such as ball games, concerts and the like to resume with few restrictions.
“Herd immunity would mean that we could start getting back together again. But we’re not going to know that we’re at herd immunity. There’s no magical ‘all of the sudden we’re at 72% and we’re safe,’” she said. “The things we’re going to monitor are the number of cases per week … and as long as it trends down and stays below 10 or 5 per 100,000 and we have decent testing [numbers] in the state, then we’ll know that it’s safe to get people back together.”
The vaccination push is also cutting down on the number of COVID patients who require hospitalization. After a surge in early January that stretched hospitals to capacity limits, the number of COVID inpatients has declined dramatically, nearly three-fourths lower statewide as of Tuesday’s data from the Alabama Department of Public Health.
“If that number keeps driving down and we see fewer and fewer people hospitalized, even though they’ve been infected, then we can start moving around again,” Judd said. “We all live with viruses every day. We’ve lived with them before [COVID]. But the problem with this one is that it sent a lot of people to the hospital, and it killed a lot of people. If this virus becomes … less strong, because of the vaccines or because of our natural immunity, and it keeps people out of the hospital and keeps people from dying, then we can get back together again.”
Judd said her staff members’ spirits are being lifted by the good news.
“The mood is up. There’s just a general feeling of relief,” she said. “We’re starting to see the edge of the woods, the light at the end of the tunnel.”
Editor’s Note: UAB hold WBHM’s broadcast license, but our news and business departments operate independently.
How treatable is prostate cancer? A doctor reacts to Biden’s diagnosis
Prostate cancer is one of the most common types of cancer in the U.S., and often treatable. One urologist says Biden has good options ahead — largely thanks to recent advances in research.
IRS sued by watchdog group for records on Trump’s attacks on Harvard
Watchdog group American Oversight takes Trump administration to court over the alleged withholding of information related to Harvard University's tax-exempt status
Trump threatened school funding in Maine. Here’s how that money is used
Schools in Maine are in the middle of a political and legal battle between the Trump administration and Gov. Janet Mills. Key programs for the most vulnerable students are at stake.
Where does your weather forecast come from?
Whether you get your forecast from an app on your phone, a website or a meteorologist on TV, most of the underlying information comes from the federal government.
How President Trump is sparking a crypto revolution in America
Crypto exchange giant Coinbase is set to join the S&P 500 on Monday. It's the latest stunning development as Trump completely revamps the approach to crypto in the U.S.
How new at-home HPV test kits could help Alabama fight cervical cancer
The Food and Drug Administration has approved the country’s first at-home HPV screening kit, a disease that causes nearly all cervical cancers. While some hope the new kits might turn things around, others have questions.
