Birmingham City Council Approves Software For Police Department’s Real-Time Crime Center
The Birmingham City Council voted Tuesday to implement new software for the Birmingham Police Department’s real-time crime center, despite public concerns that the agreement could pave the way for facial recognition software to be used by city law enforcement.
The resolution will allow the city to lease-purchase rights to Motorola Solutions’ CommandCentral Aware and BriefCam softwares at a total cost of $1,315,659 over a five-year period.
Fifteen residents — several of whom had also vocally opposed Mayor Randall Woodfin’s FY 2021 budget — spoke against the proposed agreement at Tuesday’s meeting, expressing concerns that BriefCam’s capability for facial recognition could have a negative impact on residents, particularly Black people, who are misidentified by such software far more often than white people.
“I believe that this software, if fully implemented, can easily lead to violations (such as) unreasonable searches and other problems that are present on the Bill of Rights,” said Joseph Baker, one of the residents speaking out against the proposal. “The algorithms have been shown to be faulty… Surely the forthcoming legal challenges that will be brought forth by myself and others will cost this city more than the $1.315 million that you are going to allocate to this.
“This will not stand,” he said. “We will not allow the city’s power and authority to be turned against the citizens of this community, because the people are the city.”
Woodfin argued that the purpose of the software was to integrate the police department’s existing data collection softwares into one system.
“You all last year approved and supported a real-time crime center,” he told the council. “If you want this real-time crime center to work, we need to purchase software that integrates all those existing softwares,” he said. “You’re not agreeing today to purchase any new equipment that relates to cameras.”
Facial recognition technology would not be used as part of the project, Woodfin said — adding that capability would require approval by the City Council. “The mayor’s office or the police department doesn’t have unilateral power to use facial recognition,” he said.
Woodfin’s comments received near-unanimous support from the council, even from District 8 Councilor Steven Hoyt, a frequent critic of the mayor.
But Hoyt went one step further, arguing that the city could and should use facial recognition technology.
“You can’t say, ‘I’m going to build a house but I’m not going to use the restroom,’” he said. “If it’s in the house, you’re going to use the restroom. If (the software) has the capability of facial recognition, guess what’s going to happen? You’re going to use it… And we’ve got to use it. I’m going to vote for it because I know we’ve got to have every tool we can garner to fight crime, because it’s out of hand.”
Several councilors reiterated that residents they interacted with at neighborhood meetings had consistently requested more police presence in the city.
“I’m voting in favor of this because the majority of my constituents are telling me they want more and better policing, capture of criminals, prevention of crime, whatever you call it,” said District 3 Councilor Valerie Abbott, adding that her home had been burgled the day before and that, without her own security camera, police were unlikely to find the perpetrator.
“We are making capital improvements to our police department because it is what our citizens are requesting,” added District 2 Councilor Hunter Williams. “I know that it’s challenging sometimes when you have people that are constantly saying ‘no more policing,’ ‘defund the police,’ whatever… The truth is, in my district… everyone is asking for more policing, better police response, and things that can increase police presence…. I agree that facial recognition is too much of Big Brother and too much of a hyper-police state. So be it. This is not that.”
District 1 Councilor Clinton Woods suggested that a separate ordinance preventing the use of facial recognition software in the city would “solve the conflict.”
“I think people are off as far as what the software is,” he said.
The council voted to approve the item 8-1. District 5 Councilor Darrell O’Quinn, who noted he had “some reservations about how we’re doing this and will vote my conscience,” cast the sole “no” vote.
After the meeting, Councilor Darrell O’Quinn told BirminghamWatch that his issue with the resolution was its funding source.
“BPD is utilizing a line of credit to fund this initiative,” he wrote. “The Council agreed to this prior to the pandemic and the resulting economic downturn. The hardship the City is experiencing and that was manifested in the recently passed budget is very much a concern. Given the severe change in the City’s financial circumstances, my vote today reflected my concern for taking on a new debt obligation in the midst of a projected $63M shortfall in revenue.
There were definitely additional concerns that factored into my decision, but the means by which we are financing this project was a major consideration.”
How Alabama Power kept bills up and opposition out to become one of the most powerful utilities in the country
In one of the poorest states in America, the local utility earns massive profits producing dirty energy with almost no pushback from state regulators.
No more Elmo? APT could cut ties with PBS
The board that oversees Alabama Public Television is considering disaffiliating from PBS, ending a 55-year relationship.
Nonprofit erases millions in medical debt across Gulf South, says it’s ‘Band-Aid’ for real issue
Undue Medical Debt has paid off more than $299 million in medical debts in Alabama. Now, the nonprofit warns that the issue could soon get worse.
Roy Wood Jr. on his father, his son and his new book
Actor, comedian and writer Roy Wood Jr. is out with a new book -- "The Man of Many Fathers: Life Lessons Disguised as a Memoir." He writes about his experience growing up in Birmingham, losing his dad as a teenager and all the lessons he learned from various father figures throughout his career.
Auburn fires coach Hugh Freeze following 12th loss in his last 15 SEC games
The 56-year-old Freeze failed to fix Auburn’s offensive issues in three years on the Plains, scoring 24 or fewer points in 17 of his 22 league games. He also ended up on the wrong end of too many close matchups, including twice this season thanks partly to questionable calls.
In a ‘disheartening’ era, the nation’s former top mining regulator speaks out
Joe Pizarchik, who led the federal Office of Surface Mining Reclamation and Enforcement from 2009 to 2017, says Alabama’s move in the wake of a fatal 2024 home explosion increases risks to residents living atop “gassy” coal mines.
