In Birmingham, Debate Over Confederate Monuments Renewed After Charlottesville
First heard on NPR’s All Things Considered 8-17-2017
President Trump this week weighed in on the long-simmering debate over Confederate monuments. The president tweeted that he’s sad to see the history and culture of “…our great country being ripped apart with the removal of our beautiful statues and monuments.” He went on to say you can’t change history but you can learn from it.
That debate is playing out this week in Birmingham. Following the bloody white supremacist rally in Charlottesville, Virginia, Mayor William Bell decided to cover up one of the city’s Confederate monuments.
Earlier this year, the Alabama Legislature passed a law preventing any local government from removing, relocating or altering any historical monument. This came after a wave of southern cities began to take down Confederate statues following the racially-motivated killings at a Charleston, South Carolina church in 2015.
Birmingham has long wrestled with how to portray its past. In the 1950s and 60s, some of the bloodiest events of the Civil Rights era happened here. Mayor Bell ordered a Civil War monument to be covered up.
“It’s a monument to segregation. It’s a monument to human bondage. It’s a monument to sedition and the breakup of the United States of America,” Bell says.
The base of the memorial is now wrapped by a plywood barrier to hide the inscription honoring Confederate soldiers and sailors.
Birmingham resident Mark Davis was sitting next to the memorial in Linn Park. He says it should have been removed a long time ago — in a respectful way.
“It seems like people wanted to take offense at the whole heritage thing, but I think this is a whole different question now,” he says.
LaJoya Sanders and Tonya Jackson were strolling by. They say race is complicated in the South.
“We don’t see no color and people look at us like we’re crazy because I’m white and she’s black and we’re walking together,” Jackson says.
“We can’t move forward as a community, state, city, United States, nothing because of racism,” Sanders adds. “They keep trying to hold us back in the past. But they saying, ‘let’s move on’ Why hold on to the past then?”
“Can’t live in the future — living in the past,” Jackson says.
But this week, Alabama Attorney General Steve Marshall sued the city of Birmingham for covering up the Civil War monument. Speaking to reporters this week, he said it’s not about living in the future, or the the past. It’s that the mayor broke the law.
“This has nothing to do with the Confederacy, nothing to do with the long-term history of this particular monument itself,” Marshall says.
The private group ‘United Daughters of the Confederacy’ paid for the monument in 1905. Mayor Bell says he’d like to see the monument moved to a museum where it can be displayed with perspective and context.
“But not give it a place of prominence as something for us to be proud of, or waving over someone’s head that oh, we wish the good old days were here when people of my race were subjugated to Jim Crow laws,” he says.
Bell says this statue has no place in a public park, especially for a city whose majority population is African-American. The mayor welcomes the lawsuit and says it should be up to the city — not the state — to decide how to honor and remember its racial past.
The fight to beat neglected tropical diseases was going well. 2025 could change that
The campaign to prevent and treat these diseases has seen great success thanks to a USAID program. Now that program is gone.
Greetings from Andhra Pradesh, India, where a fragrant food stand feeds working women
Far-Flung Postcards is a weekly series in which NPR's international team shares moments from their lives and work around the world.
Machado’s daughter accepts Nobel Peace Prize in Venezuelan opposition leader’s absence
Machado — who has been in hiding for nearly a year — was still expected in Oslo later in the day.
Trump’s SAVE tool is looking for noncitizen voters. But it’s flagging U.S. citizens too
Anthony Nel, of Texas, became a U.S. citizen as a teen. But a flaw in a Trump administration citizenship tool flagged him as a potential noncitizen, which led to his voter registration being canceled.
Useful tips from NPR’s most popular self-help stories of the year
A roundup of good advice from Life Kit's 10 most read stories of 2025. Find out which foods support better sleep, how to be happier and how to graciously accept compliments.
Education Department recalls fired attorneys amid civil rights complaint backlog
The department said recalling these fired staffers would "bolster and refocus" civil rights enforcement "in a way that serves and benefits parents, students, and families."
