Supporters Say Constitutional Amendment Must Pass to Preserve Hundreds of Local Laws
When voters go to the polls next month, they’ll be voting on a proposed constitutional amendment that some say has to pass or cities and towns could be thrown into legal chaos. Supporters of Amendment 14 say without its approval, hundreds of local laws across Alabama could be wiped out by legal challenges. The list includes laws related to schools to local taxes to law enforcement.
The reason’s very technical and comes out of legislative procedure.
When Alabama lawmakers meet in a regular session, the first thing they’re supposed to do is pass the budgets. But in real life, that doesn’t happen. Instead lawmakers can pass what’s called a Budget Isolation Resolution or BIR and that allows them to consider a measure before the budget is approved.
Now according to a 1984 amendment, the Alabama Constitution requires a BIR to be passed by 3/5ths of a quorum present. But Alabama House rules say these resolutions only have to be passed by 3/5ths of those voting, which is a lower threshold. So for more than 30 years, lawmakers have passed legislation based on those looser rules.
The distinction came to light after a judge ruled last year on a Jefferson County plan to refinance school construction debt and use the savings for other items. He ruled it was unconstitutional because its BIR was not passed with the higher vote requirement. The case is on appeal. But if upheld, some lawmakers worry that more than 600 laws passed in the same way could be overturned through similar lawsuits.
“You could easily challenge all of them and win pretty easily in challenging all these local acts,” says State Senator Cam Ward (R-Alabaster), who sponsored the measure that put Amendment 14 on the ballot. If passed, it would say these laws in question would be considered legitimate.
“You could still challenge the constitutionality of the local bill,” says Ward. “But you couldn’t do it just based upon how the BIR vote was counted in the legislature, which is just a procedural issue, nothing that deals with the policy substance of the bill.”
Many organizations from the Association of County Commissions to the Business Council of Alabama are encouraging a yes vote.
But Birmingham resident Bob Friedman says “no.” He’s filed a lawsuit in Montgomery to block the amendment from the ballot. He says it’s an attempt to do an end run around the courts in the Jefferson County case that’s on appeal and that violates the separation of powers. Plus, Friedman says, the constitution wasn’t followed.
“Many people have known that the quorum procedure has been violated for years,” says Friedman. “you shouldn’t go to the voters to bail you out.”
Friedman acknowledges a no vote could open up a legal avenue to challenge all these laws, but he thinks the threat is overblown. He says it takes a lot of time and money to win a lawsuit so there wouldn’t be a proliferation of cases.
Senator Cam Ward calls Friedman’s lawsuit a stunt. He argues, if there were a violation, it’s the court that interfered with lawmakers by focusing on a technicality. But it is a technicality that could have far reaching consequences for cities and towns across Alabama.
Friedman Complaint by WBHM News on Scribd
Alabama Senate advances Birmingham Water Works Board overhaul
A fight erupted this week in the Alabama legislature over a bill that would remake the Birmingham Water Works Board. We dive into that controversy and talk about other legislative action with Todd Stacy, host of Capital Journal and Alabama Public Television.
How to watch Pope Francis’s funeral, and what to expect
Pope Francis's funeral begins in Vatican City at 4 a.m. ET on Saturday and will end with his burial in Rome. Here's what to know about the day's events — and how Francis is breaking with tradition.
Trump pushes Russia-Ukraine peace deal. And, NPR’s glimpse inside liberated Khartoum
Russia launched a deadly strike on the Ukrainian capital of Kyiv. Trump says he wants peace quickly. And, NPR looks inside Sudan's capital city of Khartoum after two years of war.
Damage from gut bacteria may play a role in the rise in colon cancer in young adults
Scientists have a new clue in the mystery of why younger people are getting more colon cancer. It may have to do with a toxin produced by a common gut microbe.
New analysis casts doubt on ‘biosignatures’ found on planet K2-18b
Researchers using data from the James Webb Space Telescope recently announced they had detected biosignature gases on planet K2-18b. A new analysis of the same data casts doubt on the earlier findings
Dear Life Kit: I’m not sure about her sexuality. Should I try to kiss her anyway?
An NPR listener writes: "We've briefly discussed sexuality, but I have no idea how fluid she may be, if at all. " Plus: A woman wants to marry her partner, but his family constantly belittles her. Is the relationship doomed?
