Alabama’s Death Penalty System Faces New Scrutiny

 ========= Old Image Removed =========1618971785 
1453441688

Alabama executed a death row inmate Thursday evening for the first time in more than two years. Christopher Brooks died by lethal injection for the 1992 rape and murder of a Homewood woman. But Alabama’s death penalty system is facing new scrutiny after a U.S. Supreme Court decision this month overturning Florida’s process.

Florida, Alabama and Delaware are the only states that use what’s called “judicial override.”

Here’s how it works.

If a jury convicts a person of a capital offense, the jury then recommends a sentence of life without parole or death. A judge can decide to follow that recommendation or override it. But the key is the judge makes the decision.

Ashley Cleek reported on Alabama’s judicial override system for the podcast Life of the Law. She cites numbers from the non-profit law firm Equal Justice Initiative that show Alabama judges have imposed the death penalty against the recommendation of juries at least 101 times since 1981. About 40 current Alabama death row inmates received sentences this way.

Cleek spoke to a handful of jurors involved in capital murder trials. Some were fine letting the judge make the decision, figuring he or she had more expertise. But not all jurors saw it that way.

“They were pretty upset about it,” Cleek says. “They really felt that their time had been wasted and they didn’t really understand the point of them being there.”

The U.S. Supreme Court ruling in the Florida case determined that jurors do play a critical role, that a “mere recommendation is not enough” for the death penalty, and so Florida’s system is unconstitutional.

“I think every judge that has a capital case in front of her or him right now is focused on this,” says Samford University law professor LaJuana Davis.

She says the ruling’s effect should be felt in Alabama since the state’s statute is very similar to Florida’s. The big question is if the decision applies retroactively. In other words, does it apply to inmates already on death row? At a minimum, Davis thinks it will prompt challenges from Alabama.

“I suspect that everyone who has been sentenced to death here will be filing something,” says Davis.

In a statement, Alabama Attorney General Luther Strange says the Supreme Court ruling doesn’t affect the state. He says the court upheld Alabama’s system in 1995 and declined to hear a challenge last year.

 

Once praised, settlement to help sickened BP oil spill workers leaves most with nearly nothing

Thousands of ordinary people who helped clean up after the 2010 BP oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico say they got sick. A court settlement was supposed to help compensate them, but it hasn’t turned out as expected.

Q&A: How harm reduction can help mitigate the opioid crisis

Maia Szalavitz discusses harm reduction's effectiveness against drug addiction, how punitive policies can hurt people who need pain medication and more.

The Gulf States Newsroom is hiring a Community Engagement Producer

The Gulf States Newsroom is seeking a curious, creative and collaborative professional to work with our regional team to build up engaged journalism efforts.

Gambling bills face uncertain future in the Alabama legislature

This year looked to be different for lottery and gambling legislation, which has fallen short for years in the Alabama legislature. But this week, with only a handful of meeting days left, competing House and Senate proposals were sent to a conference committee to work out differences.

Alabama’s racial, ethnic health disparities are ‘more severe’ than other states, report says

Data from the Commonwealth Fund show that the quality of care people receive and their health outcomes worsened because of the COVID-19 pandemic.

What’s your favorite thing about Alabama?

That's the question we put to those at our recent News and Brews community pop-ups at Hop City and Saturn in Birmingham.

More Front Page Coverage