The school shooting industry is worth billions – and it keeps growing

On a sunny day in Grapevine, Texas, three drones are buzzing around the head of a test dummy balanced on a pedestal. It’s part of a demonstration outside the National School Safety Conference.

“We use drones to stop school shootings,” says Justin Marston, the CEO of Campus Guardian Angel, the company selling the drones. In the event of a shooting, remote pilots fly the drones, housed at the school, at the shooter. They shoot pepper balls and run the drones into the shooter to debilitate them.

The technology is one example on a long list of products schools can buy to deter a shooter.

There have been more than 400 school shootings since Columbine in 1999, according to an analysis by The Washington Post. The latest was last month, when a former student opened fire at a Catholic school in Minneapolis. Two students were killed and at least 18 others were wounded.

In the wake of those shootings, an industry has emerged to try to protect schools — and business is booming. According to the market research firm Omdia, the school security industry is now worth as much as $4 billion, and it’s projected to keep growing.

A test dummy, from the company Campus Guardian Angel, stands ready to be attacked by drones in a demonstration at the National School Safety Conference in Grapevine, Texas. The drones are the company's answer to deterring a school shooter.
A test dummy, from the company Campus Guardian Angel, stands ready to be attacked by drones in a demonstration at the National School Safety Conference in Grapevine, Texas. The drones are the company’s answer to deterring a school shooter. (Meg Anderson | NPR)

“The school safety and security industry has grown rapidly over the past decade,” says Sonali Rajan, senior director with the research arm of Everytown for Gun Safety, which advocates for gun control. “The challenge right now is that these school safety products, the vast majority, have absolutely no evidence guiding their effectiveness.”

What’s for sale

Inside the school safety conference, vendors in an expo hall showcase panic buttons, bullet-resistant whiteboards, facial recognition technology, training simulators, body armor, guns and tasers.

Tom McDermott, with the metal detector manufacturer CEIA USA, says schools used to be a small fraction of their U.S. business. Now they’re the majority.

“It’s not right. We need to solve this problem. It’s good for business, but we don’t need to be selling to schools,” McDermott says.

Sarah McNeeley, a sales manager with SAM Medical, is selling trauma kits, which include tourniquets, clotting agents and chest seals. She says their customers are traditionally EMTs, fire departments, and military medics, but increasingly, school districts.

“Being prepared and having these devices in the schools is essential,” she says. “Some people want to put their heads in the sand and pretend like it’s not going to happen to them.”

Firearms sit on a display table for Springfield Armory, a gun manufacturer, in the expo hall at the National School Safety Conference in Grapevine, Texas. School resource officers, who are sworn police stationed in schools, are usually armed, and several firearm manufacturers attended the conference.
Firearms sit on a display table for Springfield Armory, a gun manufacturer, in the expo hall at the National School Safety Conference in Grapevine, Texas. School resource officers, who are sworn police stationed in schools, are usually armed, and several firearm manufacturers attended the conference. (Meg Anderson | NPR)

The expo hall is just one part of the conference, organized by the National Association of School Resource Officers, or NASRO. The group also trains school-based police officers on a variety of topics, including how to work with kids who have experienced trauma, and how to intervene before violence occurs.

Sarah Mendoza, a school resource officer in Yoakum, Texas, who attended the conference, says she finds that aspect most meaningful.

“I just sit there and I talk to them and I listen,” she says of working with students. “My connection with the kids is so important because they’re the ones who are going to come and tell me, ‘Hey Mendoza, this is what’s going on. Can you help us?’ or ‘Hey Mendoza, this is how I’m feeling today. What can I do to make myself better?'”

Mo Canady, the executive director of NASRO and a former police officer, says school resource officers are in one of the most challenging policing roles.

“We’re asking a lot of that officer. We’re asking them to be the best tactical person their department could offer,” Canady says. “We’re asking them to be the best informal counselor.”

But when a shooting happens, he says school resource officers need any tools they can get.

What works to prevent school shootings

Gun violence experts say simple things like locked doors can make a difference. Authorities say that likely saved many lives last month in Minneapolis. But a locked door doesn’t necessarily prevent a shooting.

Researchers say investing in school communities that promote a culture of emotional support and trust, as well as robust mental health services, are key to preventing gun violence, as most school shooters are current or former students and are suicidal.

Jillian Peterson, who leads the Violence Prevention Project Research Center at Hamline University, has interviewed people who planned a school shooting, but didn’t carry it out. She said there are often two key reasons they change their minds: The first is that they had trouble accessing a firearm – which is why, she says, safe storage laws are crucial.

The other is that someone helped a young person find hope while they were in crisis.

“We’re spending billions of dollars that could be going to mental health or counselors, all the stuff that we know creates inclusion,” Peterson says.

Still, she says, she understands the allure of an impenetrable school.

“I think it preys on people’s worst fears,” she says. “How do you say no to something if you’re telling me it might save my kid’s life? Of course I want that thing.”

She said trying to buy safety feels very American, just like school shootings.

Transcript:

MARY LOUISE KELLY, HOST:

Many children are just beginning a new school year, but it is one already touched by tragedy. A former student opened fire at a Catholic school in Minneapolis in August. Two children were killed, at least 18 were wounded. That’s the latest in the more than 400 school shootings that have happened since Columbine, according to data from The Washington Post. Since then, a multibillion-dollar industry has emerged around school security. NPR’s Meg Anderson takes us on a trip to see what’s for sale.

MEG ANDERSON, BYLINE: It’s a steamy day in Grapevine, Texas.

(SOUNDBITE OF DRONE BUZZING)

ANDERSON: But that buzzing you hear, it’s not mosquitos. It’s a drone.

JUSTIN MARSTON: We use drones to stop school shootings.

ANDERSON: That’s Justin Marston. He’s the CEO of Campus Guardian Angel, and he’s selling these drones. We’re outside the National School Safety Conference. Three pilots are doing a demonstration.

(SOUNDBITE OF DRONES BUZZING)

ANDERSON: The drones are whizzing around like tiny helicopters, circling a test dummy on a pedestal. He’s the shooter in this demo.

UNIDENTIFIED DRONE OPERATOR: Go in a little high here. Pick up some altitude.

ANDERSON: The drones are meant to disorient. They can even spit out pepper balls. Eventually, they’ll ram into the dummy, knocking it to the ground like a bowling pin. This technology is just one example on a long list of things schools can buy to try to deter a mass shooter. Business is booming.

SONALI RAJAN: The school safety and security industry has grown rapidly over the past decade in particular.

ANDERSON: Sonali Rajan is with the research arm of Everytown for Gun Safety, which advocates for gun control. According to the market research firm Omdia, the school security industry is now worth as much as $4 billion, and it’s projected to keep growing.

RAJAN: The challenge right now is that these school safety products, the vast majority of these have absolutely no evidence guiding their effectiveness.

ANDERSON: Inside the School Safety Conference, there’s an expo hall and a lot more for sale. Down the aisles, people are selling panic buttons, bulletproof whiteboards, facial recognition technology, training simulators, body armor, guns and tasers. Sarah McNeely, with SAM Medical, is selling stop-the-bleed kits.

SARAH MCNEELY: Tourniquet. Trauma shears.

ANDERSON: She says their customers are EMTs, fire departments, military medics, but increasingly, school districts. Tom McDermott is with CEIA USA, a company that makes metal detectors. He says schools used to be a small fraction of their U.S. business. Now, they’re the majority.

TOM MCDERMOTT: Which is nuts. You consider the Secret Service use us. Major League Baseball, NFL, theme parks, they use us. It’s not right. I mean, we need to solve this problem. It’s good for business, but we don’t need to be selling to schools.

ANDERSON: Mo Canady leads the National Association of School Resource Officers, the group that organizes this conference. He says the expo hall is just one part of the gathering. They also train school police officers on how to work with kids who have experienced trauma and how to intervene before violence occurs.

MO CANADY: We’re asking a lot of that officer.

ANDERSON: So, he says, when a shooting happens, they need whatever tools they can get. Gun violence experts say simple things like locked doors can make a difference. Authorities say that likely saved many lives last month in Minneapolis. But that doesn’t necessarily prevent a shooting. Jill Peterson, a criminology professor at Hamline University, says people who plan a shooting but don’t carry it out often change their minds for two reasons. One is that they can’t access a gun. The other is that someone helps them when they’re in crisis.

JILL PETERSON: We’re spending billions of dollars that could be going to mental health or counselors.

ANDERSON: Still, she says, she understands the allure of an impenetrable school.

PETERSON: And I think it preys on people’s worst fears, right? Like, how do you say no to something if you’re telling me it might save my kid’s life? Of course I want that thing.

ANDERSON: She says trying to buy our way to safety feels very American, just like school shootings.

Meg Anderson, NPR News.

 

Nepal lifts social media ban following protests where police killed 19 people

Nepal's government lifted its ban on social media platforms Tuesday a day after police killed opened fire on mass street protests against the ban, killing 19 people.

Rick Davies, singer and co-founder of Supertramp, has died

The British musician co-founded the rock band Supertramp, which spurred hits like "Give A Little Bit" and "The Logical Song" in the 1970s.

Rupert Murdoch buys out 3 of his kids, cementing his conservative media empire

The owner of Fox News, the Wall Street Journal and dozens of other media properties has settled a legal fight with three of his own children over who would control his companies after his death.

Estate of Jeffrey Epstein gives Congress ‘birthday book’ allegedly signed by Trump

Democrats on the House Oversight Committee said the book included a tawdry drawing and note that appeared to include President Trump's signature. Trump had previously denied its existence.

DHS launches immigration crackdowns in Chicago, Boston

These announcements by DHS are just the latest escalation of federal action in U.S. cities including Los Angeles and Washington, D.C. — all led by Democrats.

New teen thriller ‘Sisters in the Wind’ finds drama in hidden identities

Angeline Boulley, author of the hit Firekeeper's Daughter, writes thrillers set in Native American communities in northern Michigan, like the ones where her family has lived for generations.

More Front Page Coverage