Supreme Court allows Mississippi social media law to go into effect

The Supreme Court on Thursday refused to intervene on a lower court decision that affirmed a Mississippi law requiring users to verify their ages before using social media sites such as Facebook, Instagram, and Snapchat.

The Mississippi law is far broader than a Supreme Court ruling just weeks ago that upheld a Texas law mandating age verification to access websites with sexually explicit material. Writing for the court’s conservative supermajority, in June, Justice Clarence Thomas held that requiring adults to verify their age prior to using sexually explicit sites did not violate the First Amendment’s Free Speech Clause because it is important to shield “children from sexually explicit content.”

In contrast, the Mississippi law requires all users to verify their ages before using common social media sites ranging from Facebook to Nextdoor, a social media site that connects people to their nearby neighbors.

In addition to the age verification rule, the Mississippi law requires social media websites to work to prevent children from accessing “harmful materials” and prohibits minors from using social media websites, such as Instagram and Youtube, without parental consent.

NetChoice, a tech industry association committed to “protecting online freedom” sued, arguing that the law unconstitutionally restricted nine of its member websites: websites mentioned above, including Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube.

Netchoice argues that the law violates the First Amendment’s guarantee of free speech without governmental interference. The “monitoring-and-censorship requirements for vague categories of speech,” Netchoice argued, limits individuals’ access to important information ranging from university professors’ online lectures, to statements from political leaders, and other creative content.

Though it is within parents’ interests to protect their children from harmful content, said NetChoice, there are other tools—such as web browser parental controls—that parents can use to regulate their children’s online use.

A district court agreed with Netchoice, temporarily stopping the Mississippi law from going into effect while proceedings continued in the lower courts. But, the conservative Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals lifted the temporary block, without addressing whether or not the law violates the First Amendment.

Justice Brett Kavanaugh, concurred with the court’s order Thursday, but wrote: “In short, under this Court’s case law as it currently stands, the Mississippi law is likely unconstitutional. Nonetheless, because NetChoice has not sufficiently demonstrated that the balance of harms and equities favors it at this time, I concur in the Court’s denial of the application for interim relief.”

The Supreme Court refused to block the Fifth Circuit’s decision, allowing at least temporarily, for the Mississippi law to go into effect.

 

What we know about the Dallas ICE facility shooting

A gunman fired at a Dallas ICE immigration detention facility, killing one person and injuring two others. Investigators provide updates on the shooting and the gunman.

Trump is accusing the U.N. of ‘sabotage.’ The U.N. says Trump’s team is to blame

Trump says three "sinister events" disrupted his speech: a frozen escalator, a broken teleprompter and a too-quiet sound system. The U.N. says Trump's team is at fault, but opened an investigation.

Starbucks is closing more stores and laying off 900 workers

The coffee giant plans to cut 900 corporate jobs and shut down about 1% of its stores as the chain's turnaround plan approaches a one-year mark.

Amazon to pay $2.5 billion to settle U.S. lawsuit that it ‘tricked’ people into Prime

Federal regulators say Amazon has agreed to pay a historic sum to resolve their allegations that its web designs manipulated millions of people into paying for Prime subscriptions, which were also purposefully hard to cancel. Affected shoppers are slated to receive payouts.

Twenty One Pilots prove rock’s not dead atop the ‘Billboard’ albums chart

Rock and roll is alive and well atop the Billboard 200 albums chart this week, as Twenty One Pilots' Breach hits No. 1.

VIDEO: Top health officials are at odds with scientists. Who should Americans believe?

President Trump linked Tylenol to autism despite little medical evidence. How are Americans meant to make important decisions about their health at this confusing moment?

More Front Page Coverage