Opinion: ‘Free speech doesn’t work just when you agree with it’
In 1977, a neo-Nazi group called the National Socialist Party of America applied for a permit to march through Skokie, Illinois, a predominantly Jewish, Chicago suburb. They wanted to wear brown shirts with swastika armbands and wave signs demanding “free speech for white people.”
The village refused the permit. The group sued, and it ignited a national debate over the First Amendment that may sound familiar today. Does the constitutional right to free speech protect offensive, even hateful speech? Can words cause real damage?
Skokie’s attorneys argued that seeing the swastika and hearing chants of “Sieg Heil” on their streets would amount to a physical attack on the hundreds of Holocaust survivors who lived in Skokie.
I remember speaking with Magda Brown over iced tea on her porch. She’d been a teenager in Hungary when the Nazi-aligned government began making anti-Jewish laws. She survived Auschwitz and Buchenwald. Her family was executed.
“The thought of Nazis in our streets today,” she told me, “brings back my worst fears.”
I told Magda Brown that the young Chicago Nazis I’d interviewed in their small storefront headquarters looked more ridiculous than menacing. Magda answered, “That’s what the Nazis looked like to us in 1933, too,” — the year Hitler came to power in Germany.
David Goldberger was the ACLU lawyer who argued in the U.S. Supreme Court for the right of the neo-Nazis to march and speak.
“But our real client was always the First Amendment,” he told us this week. The courts eventually ruled that the planned demonstration was protected speech, but the Nazis ended up holding their rally in Chicago instead.
David Goldberger, who is now professor emeritus at The Ohio State University’s law school, found the case personally painful. He himself is Jewish.
“I still feel bad about the pain it caused survivors,” he said. “People who had suffered so much. I felt like they could be my uncles and relatives.”
“But when free speech is denied because someone finds it offensive,” he says today, “then officials can prevent speech, even jokes, that anyone dislikes for any reason. Free speech doesn’t work just when you agree with it.”
Maybe there’s some unity in that thought in these divided times.
Claudette Colvin, who refused to move seats on a bus at start of civil rights movement, dies at 86
Colvin, at age 15, was arrested nine months before Rosa Parks gained international fame for also refusing to give up her seat on a segregated bus.
Republicans say Clintons risk contempt of Congress for not testifying on Epstein
House Republicans are seeking testimony as part of their investigation into convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein. The Clintons say they've already provided in writing what little they know.
FTC accuses AI search engine of ‘rampant consumer deception’
Federal officials say a company that operates hundreds of landing pages for AI answers is running an operation that has duped thousands of users, who were unable to stop costly monthly charges.
How Minnesota faith communities are resisting aggressive immigration operations
As immigration enforcement actions have ramped up in Minnesota, people of faith have been at the forefront of the response to ICE detentions and the killing of Renee Macklin Good by a federal agent.
‘My role was making movies that mattered,’ says Jodie Foster, as ‘Taxi Driver’ turns 50
Foster was just 12 years old when she starred in the 1976 film. "What luck to have been part of that, our golden age of cinema in the '70s," she says. Her latest film is Vie Privée (A Private Life).
Supreme Court appears likely to uphold state bans on transgender athletes
To date, 27 states have enacted laws barring transgender participation in sports.
