Israel takes steps to shut down international aid groups in Gaza and the West Bank
AMMAN, Jordan — Israel, having banned the United Nations aid agency for Palestinian refugees from sending aid and staff to Gaza, is now taking unprecedented steps to de-register major nongovernmental aid groups for ideological reasons, according to several officials of humanitarian organizations.
They say the new rules threaten the ability of some of the biggest international nongovernmental organizations — known as INGOs — to send in aid or staff to both Gaza and the Israeli-occupied West Bank.
“INGOs are in limbo — most who have submitted have either been not accepted or rejected,” an official with an aid organization that is aware of the situation said of the application process required for nongovernmental aid organizations operating in Gaza and the West Bank. The official spoke on the condition that NPR not name their employer and not give their name because they are not authorized to speak publicly.
The ceasefire agreement in the Gaza war brokered this month by President Trump committed Israel to a surge in aid into Gaza, where food security experts declared famine in parts of the territory. But Israel continues to severely restrict crossings open for aid shipments and who can send aid through them. Of seven Israeli border crossings with Gaza, only two are currently open. Of those that are open, the U.N. and nongovernmental aid groups say many requests to enter Gaza are routinely rejected, without explanation.
The Israeli military has claimed, without providing evidence, that its aid restrictions are needed for security.
Israel this fall began requiring that all international aid groups re-register under new criteria, including approval by a committee which includes representatives from Israel’s Ministry for Diaspora Affairs and Combating Antisemitism.
Reasons for delisting aid groups include supporting “terrorist groups and activities in accordance with Israel law” and “inciting racism,” according to COGAT, the Israeli military’s arm that is part of NGO approval process. Aid organizations say the reasoning appears to be used to refer to a wide variety of comments the Israeli government classifies as antisemitic. Israel has in the past accused some aid groups and medical providers of being terrorist organizations.
Israel had also demanded that organizations provide personnel details for all local and international staff, a measure rejected by most major aid groups as potentially putting staff in danger.
The Norwegian Refugee Council, registered in Gaza since 2009, is one of the major aid groups unable to send in supplies or staff while its application is being considered.
“We quickly realized that the intent behind the process wasn’t to facilitate the re-registration of humanitarian INGOs but rather to find a way to re-register us and to remove our ability to operate,” says Ivan Karakashian, communications manager for the NRC in Jerusalem.
He says there were no clear guidelines as to what delegitimizing Israel included. Any de-registered organizations would have to cease operations in both Gaza and the Israeli occupied West Bank within 60 days, according to aid officials familiar with the criteria.
The Israeli military arm responsible for borders and coordination with INGO operations did not respond to NPR’s requests for comment on reasons for de-registering or delaying registration of some organizations.
Many of those aid groups waiting to be re-registered have had hundreds of trucks waiting for months in Egypt and Jordan intended for Gaza.
Humanitarian officials said at least one major U.S.-based NGO has already been de-registered and is now in the appeal process. The organization in question declined to discuss the issue with NPR.
Another U.S.-based aid group, Mercy Corps, said following the ceasefire agreement, it had submitted a request to send in aid but it was denied by Israeli authorities because the organization was in the process of re-registering.
Humanitarian officials said Israel has approved a dozen NGOs that do not coordinate within traditional U.N.-led structures and are either ideologically driven or have little experience in humanitarian aid or both. They include one U.S. aid group that partnered with the controversial Gaza Humanitarian Foundation — a militarized aid response in which almost all other aid groups refused to participate.
COGAT did not respond to a request for comment on new aid organizations given registration.
At the same time, Israel continues to ban the U.N. agency for providing aid to Palestinian refugees, known as UNRWA, from sending in aid or staff to Gaza. Israel accused UNRWA, without evidence, of employing hundreds of Hamas members, including some involved in the Oct. 7, 2023, attack in Israel. It has sought since the start of the Gaza war to replace the U.N. aid system that has provided humanitarian assistance there for decades.
UNRWA, with 12,000 local staff, was the biggest humanitarian organization in Gaza, running shelters, mobile medical clinics, water and sanitation projects and schools.
“The warehouses in Jordan and Egypt are full of food that can feed the entire population of Gaza for three months and we need to bring that in,” says Tamara Alrifai, UNRWA’s director of external relations. The supplies also include medicine, tents, blankets and hygiene products.
Israeli airstrikes have damaged or destroyed more than 90% of homes in Gaza and most of the civilian infrastructure, according to U.N. figures.
The United States, which had been UNRWA’s biggest donor, stopped its funding last year, which Alrifai says led to a loss of about one-quarter of UNRWA’s total income. Alrifai says while European and other countries have increased their contributions, it does not fill the funding gap. The European Union’s top humanitarian aid official said after the Israeli accusations against UNRWA he saw no evidence from Israel backing them.
Alrifai says UNRWA was trying to start discussions with the U.S. through other countries about renewing the funding.
“We have not had direct talks but we have passed on messages through other governments who are close to Gaza and close to the U.S.” she says.
Aya Batrawy contributed reporting from Dubai, United Arab Emirates.
Transcript:
SCOTT SIMON, HOST:
Israeli strikes in Gaza continue despite its military pulling back troops under a U.S.-brokered ceasefire that took effect last week. Today, an attack killed a Palestinian family of 11, including seven children and three women. Israel also committed under the ceasefire to dramatically increase the amount of aid it allows in. Aid groups say that isn’t happening. NPR’s Jane Arraf joins us now. Jane, thanks for being with us.
JANE ARRAF, BYLINE: Thank you, Scott.
SIMON: What’s happened in this attack, and what’s happening with the ceasefire?
ARRAF: Well, Gaza Civil Defense authorities say this was one of the many families returning to inspect the ruins of their home in Gaza City when Israeli forces fired a tank round at their minibus. The Israeli military said that the family was behind the yellow line where its troops are positioned and that they fired on it because they were an imminent threat. That yellow line, Scott, is visible on the map, we have to note, but not so much to families on the ground. And the ceasefire itself, it’s still holding overall, but Israel still controls more than 50% of Gaza territory. It says it plans to mark that yellow line with a physical barrier.
SIMON: Israel also pledged to allow 600 aid trucks per day into Gaza. Has that happened?
ARRAF: It hasn’t. The U.N. says that 600 is the bare minimum to keep people from starving, to provide shelter and repair infrastructure in what is a totally devastated territory. Israel is still keeping shut one of those main border crossings, Rafah, which is Egypt’s border crossing with Gaza. And that’s where many hundreds of trucks have been waiting for months to be allowed in. It has been allowing aid through two other crossings. But there, it’s a bit of a numbers game because Israel refers to all trucks as aid trucks.
So just to give you an example, two days ago, the figures show 950 trucks entered Gaza. But a Trump administration official shed some light on that. It appears that only about 10% of that figure were U.N. or international aid organizations, and most of the rest were commercial imports. Those are imports from Israel, by the way.
SIMON: And the United Nations has urged Israel to allow the aid organization with which it partners to continue to send aid into Gaza. Help us understand that.
ARRAF: Yeah. That’s a huge issue which hasn’t received a lot of attention. The U.N. doesn’t need to be registered, but international nongovernmental organizations, INGOs, do. And Israel this year said it would shut down aid groups that didn’t reregister under the new criteria, so it’s begun that process. This criteria has a committee that determines whether the organizations have delegitimized Israel through statements or anything else. Here’s Ivan Karakashian, the communications manager at the Norwegian Refugee Council in Jerusalem.
IVAN KARAKASHIAN: We quickly realized that this wasn’t – the intent behind the process wasn’t to facilitate the reregistration of INGOs, of humanitarian INGOs, but rather to find a way to deregister us – right? – and to remove our ability to operate within the occupied Palestinian territory.
ARRAF: He says his organization is in the process of trying to reregister, and that also applies to some of the biggest U.S. aid groups. If they don’t, if they can’t, that means they’re shut down.
SIMON: Jane, the United Nations agency for Palestinian refugees, known as UNRWA, was the biggest provider of aid in Gaza for decades before Israel banned staff and shipments there. Is that expected to change?
ARRAF: Israel hasn’t given any indication it’s lifting that ban. It had claimed – without evidence – that hundreds of UNRWA staff are Hamas. And the U.S. also cut funding to UNRWA. Some of that funding, but not all of it, was made up by other countries. I spoke with UNRWA’s head of external relations, Tamara Alrifai, and here’s what she had to say.
TAMARA ALRIFAI: We still are trying to work our way back into discussions with the U.S. You know how they say it takes a village? It takes an international community to want the situation in Gaza, in the occupied Palestinian territory and in the region to be stable.
ARRAF: UNRWA has been banned by Israel from sending in supplies since March. It has warehouses in Egypt and here in Jordan full of food that UNRWA says could feed the entire population of Gaza for three months.
SIMON: NPR’s Jane Arraf. Thanks so much.
ARRAF: Thank you.
Pardoned Capitol rioter arrested for allegedly threatening to kill Hakeem Jeffries
New York State Police say the man was arrested after they received word from the FBI that that he made "threats to kill a member of Congress."
Reversing peanut advice prevented tens of thousands of allergy cases, researchers say
A decade ago, research said giving young children peanut products can prevent allergies. A new study says that, 10 years later, tens of thousands of U.S. children have avoided allergies as a result.
New books this week dance between genres — and deserve your attention
New releases this week include a feminist history of modern Russia, and a candid portrait of Gish Jen's relationship with her mother. Plus, new novels from Philip Pullman and Claire Louise-Bennett.
5 things to know about Sanae Takaichi, Japan’s first female prime minister
Japan ranks low in gender equality among developed nations. The first woman to lead the country is an ultraconservative who cites Margaret Thatcher as a role model. She also loves heavy metal.
Books about race and gender to be returned to school libraries on some military bases
The order is to be implemented at school libraries on military bases in Kentucky, Virginia, Italy and Japan. Students and their families claimed their First Amendment rights had been violated when officials removed the books to comply with President Trump's executive orders.
Just because she won a Nobel doesn’t mean Malala didn’t break some rules in college
In 2014, Malala Yousafzai became the youngest person to win a Nobel Prize, an honor that weighed on her when she went off to college. In Finding My Way, she writes about her life at Oxford and beyond.
