Deceptive drug tests ensnare new parents and babies
Imagine giving birth and then testing positive for a drug. Except you didn’t take any drugs. Still the state Department of Human Resources opens an investigation based on that erroneous test. This happened to a Huntsville woman and this type of incident is more common than you might think.
That’s the finding of an investigation by Shoshana Walter, a staff writer at the Marshall Project who reported this story in partnership with the public radio program Reveal. She spoke with WBHM’s Andrew Yeager.
The following conversation has been edited and condensed for clarity.
Tell me about Melissa Robinson. This is the woman in Huntsville.
Melissa Robinson is a local librarian in Huntsville who gave birth to her firstborn, her daughter, earlier this year in February 2024. And when she entered the hospital she was drug tested. And that drug test shockingly came back for cocaine.
Melissa is someone who does not use drugs and is very careful about what she puts into her body, especially during her pregnancy. So that was a huge surprise to her and her doctors. And based on this single drug screen of her urine the hospital reported her to the Department of Human Resources and DHR opened an investigation, which was very upsetting to Melissa and her husband.
So do we know what happened, the fact that this came back with a positive test for cocaine. I guess, how could something like that happen?
We don’t know what caused that positive, but what ended up happening is Melissa was reported to DHR. DHR opened an investigation and after the investigation was already opened a confirmation test, a second more definitive test, came back to the hospital. And it was actually negative for cocaine or any illicit substances. So this confirmation test proved that the first test result was erroneous. But despite the fact that that test was negative DHR kept the investigation open. They did a home inspection of Melissa’s house. They requested that her husband also drug test. And it wasn’t until those things were done that that the agency closed the case as unsubstantiated.
But it will remain on Melissa’s record, the fact that a case was opened and it’s really left her with a lot of fear and anxiety over this whole thing.
How common are situations like Melissa’s?
Hospitals routinely drug test women who come in to give birth to see if they’ve used substances during their pregnancies. But many hospitals are using these drug tests with false positive rates as high as 50%. So false positives are extremely common when using these tests. I met women who ate poppyseed bagels and muffins, who took heartburn medication and cold medication, extremely commonly prescribed blood pressure medications, and those all cause false positives for illicit substances on these urine drug screens.
When you talk to hospitals, when you talk to child protective services, what, if any, response did you get from them to this issue of false positive drug tests?
It really runs the gamut because east state has their own laws and policies around this. What I found is that most states are requiring hospitals to take action based on a potential exposure or a positive test. But not a single state requires hospitals to confirm those test results before reporting them to child protective services.
In Alabama, for example, infants who test positive at birth for drugs are considered to be abused or neglected and those infants are required to be reported. There’s no specific requirement related to women. But I also reviewed the rest of the law and the child welfare policies and there’s no requirement that hospitals confirm those test results before reporting them to child protective services. It leads to women who shouldn’t be in the system, families who shouldn’t be in that system, babies who shouldn’t be in that system, it leads to them getting swallowed by the system that can be very difficult to escape.
‘I literally grew up in prison’: Juvenile lifers share struggles, pleasures of coming home
Accounts of reentry are notable as juvenile cases continue to undergo review. Attorneys and advocates say progress on reviews is halting in some states.
Social Security benefits face big cuts in 2033, unless Congress acts
Trustees of the Social Security trust fund predict the fund will be exhausted in eight years. Unless Congress acts, Social Security payments will automatically drop by 23% at that time.
Democratic lawmakers press USDA for answers on sensitive data collection
35 House members said they are troubled by the Agriculture Department's plans to collect personal data from people who applied for federal food assistance, and urged the effort to "immediately cease."
Greetings from Shenyang, China, where workers sort AI data in ‘Severance’-like ways
Far-Flung Postcards is a weekly series in which NPR's international team shares snapshots of moments from their lives and work around the world.
Looking for summertime suspense? Turn up the heat with these 4 mystery novels
Maureen Corrigan recommends four great reads: El Dorado Drive, by Megan Abbott; The House on Buzzards Bay, by Dwyer Murphy; King of Ashes, by S.A. Cosby; and Murder Takes a Vacation, by Laura Lippman.
‘Labubu’ is a plush toy that is causing a frenzy. Here’s its origin story
Labubus are a global sensation — sparking long lines outside toy stores, selling out online within minutes, and listing for double or triple their original price on resale markets. Here's why.