Alabama Abortion Bill Designed to Provoke Court Challenge
Few issues are as contentious in American politics as abortion. That was on full display during an Alabama House committee hearing last week. Rachel Bryars with the conservative think tank Alabama Policy Institute addressed lawmakers, but she said was speaking as a mother. In emotional testimony, Bryars described being 22, a recent college graduate, unmarried and facing an unplanned pregnancy. Bryars says it was difficult, but she decided to have the baby.
“Today looking at my beautiful, articulate, artistic, strong, unique, nearly 14-year-old daughter, I can barely fathom how she might have been erased from existence if I followed our cultures advice,” Bryars told lawmakers.
She was there to support a bill, similar to measures introduced in other states, to significantly restrict access to abortion. Abortion opponents see this as a way to challenge the 1973 Roe v. Wade decision that legalized abortion. However, the Alabama bill goes farther than other proposals. It would ban abortion in almost all cases.
The bill would make it a felony to perform an abortion, except where there’s a “serious health risk” to the woman. There is no exception for rape or incest. The mother would not face charges.
Jenna King-Shepherd also spoke at that public hearing, but with a much different message. She had an abortion as while a senior in high school and says the decision to have the procedure is an intensely personal one that the government shouldn’t interfere with.
“People choose abortion for a million different reasons and no matter what their reason is, it’s valid,” King-Shepherd says. “No one arrives at that decision flippantly or takes it lightly.” 0:15
The bill’s sponsor, Republican State Rep. Terri Collins, says the proposal is designed to prompt a court challenge.
“We decided it would be best to just offer legislation that simply got at the heart of what Roe versus Wade discussed which was ‘Is the baby in the womb a person?” Collins says. “We believe it is.”
The bill faces opposition from the American Civil Liberties Union of Alabama. Executive Director Randall Marshall says it’s a misguided move by the state. He says there are already 14 abortion-related cases in federal courts. He says Alabama’s proposed law is unconstitutional and a legal battle would cost the state millions.
“A rational legislature would say let’s wait and see what happens with all these other cases that present the very issue we’re trying to present,” Marshall says.
Rep. Collins insists a court fight isn’t a waste of money. She says most Alabamians oppose abortion, pointing to a constitutional amendment voters passed last year that recognizes the rights of the unborn.
Florida State University law professor Mary Ziegler says there are different camps within the anti-abortion movement. She says the most common strategy had been to propose incremental changes to abortion law. But increasingly, groups pushing a more hardline approach are gaining ground. Ziegler explains there are two reasons for the shift.
“One, a bet that the court will be more receptive to this law than would have been the case a few years ago,” Ziegler says. “Two, that even if the court doesn’t go for it that it will pay off politically to be taking a more kind of absolute stand on abortion.”
Ziegler is skeptical the U.S. Supreme Court would issue a sweeping decision throwing out decades of precedent. She says any changes to the court’s view of abortion is likely to come through a series of smaller rulings.
In Alabama, the House committee last week approved the bill the same day they heard testimony. The measure has enough co-sponsors to assure passage in the House before it moves to the Senate. In the meantime, people on both sides of the debate are gearing up for that court fight should the measure make it into law.
Photo by Matt Wade
Mitski comes undone
She may be indie rock's queen of precisely rendered emotion, but on Mitski's latest album, Nothing's About to Happen to Me, warped perspectives, questionable motives and possible hauntings abound.
This quiet epic is the top-grossing Japanese live action film of all time
The Oscar-nominated Kokuho tells a compelling story about friendship, the weight of history and the torturous road to becoming a star in Japan's Kabuki theater.
The Live Nation trial could reshape the music industry. Here’s what you need to know
On Tuesday opening statements will begin for the federal antitrust trial against Live Nation, one of the largest entertainment companies in the world.
A new one-a-day-pill holds promise for HIV’s ‘forgotten population’
It's designed to take the place of complicated, multiple drug regimens that many people with HIV need to follow. And it's also beneficial because the HIV virus is always evolving.
For filmmaker Chloé Zhao, creative life was never linear
Director Chloé Zhao used meditation, somatic exercises and dance to inspire the cast and crew of this Oscar-nominated story about William Shakespeare's family.
10 new books in March offer mental vacations
March is always a big one for books – this year is no different. We call out a handful of upcoming titles for readers to put on their radars — offering a good alternative to doomscrolling.
