Backs to Wall, Birmingham BOE Approves Cuts
On Third Attempt, Birmingham School Board Passes Cost-Cutting Plan
Takeover of City Schools Still Possible, But Some Members Hope Less So
After rejecting it last week and also just eight minutes earlier, the Birmingham Board of Education
passed a slightly modified version of a $12-million state cost-cutting plan Tuesday evening.
Approved with a 5-3 vote at a heated, often confusing meeting, the plan is meant to help bring the
district’s finances in line with state law, which requires a reserve of one month’s operating expenses.
Birmingham should have about $17 million but has only $2 million in reserve.
The first attempt to pass the modified plan at this Tuesday’s meeting failed on a 4-4 vote, but soon after,
board president Edward Maddox changed his vote to yes, so it passed 5-3. Maddox and Alana Edwards,
W.J. Maye, April Williams, and Phyllis Wyne voted for the plan. Emanuel Ford, Brian Giattina and Virginia
Volker voted against it.
In another strange twist, board member Tyrone Belcher — who had been at the meeting and taken part
in board business — quietly left the premises shortly before the most important vote of the night.
Giattina, puzzled as were other board members, used the word “evaporated.”
The plan will result in cutting almost 180 positions, most of them administrators in the central office.
Changes from the original plan, originally proposed by the state team investigating the local system,
include keeping Norwood Elementary open, cutting five nursing positions instead of seven, and cutting
two social workers instead of four. The modifications that ostensibly mollified the board will result in a
reduction in savings of almost $68,000, approximately one half of one percent of the original plan.
Apparently there were other motivating factors in the board’s turnaround.
“Before the state came in, we didn’t have any conversation from anybody in this district about any
plan,” said Richard Franklin, president of the Birmingham branch of the American Federation of
Teachers.
Wyne, who’d voted for the plan at every opportunity, got more specific. Referring to the specter of a
state takeover that could still happen as early as the state school board meeting on Thursday, she said,
“[Our board] fought the state every step of the way, and now that it got down to the wire … Mr.
Maddox our president decided he wanted to do the right thing.”
Giattina added, “… the board voted a plan that they rejected last week purely to eliminate the state
from coming here and doing what I believe the community wants. They postponed it. And that’s all that
they did. I’m very frustrated. And I’m equally frustrated with the Board president and the board
communication. I was never notified of any of these changes.”
He said he voted against the plan because it contains “absolutely no fundamental change except for the
fact that the board knew what was going to happen [if they didn’t approve it].”
Several board members and others close to the situation drove home the point that all those saved
dollars will mean real people losing their jobs. Cuts could start as early as next week, and the process of
terminating people in a top-heavy and inefficiently organized school system is incredibly complicated.
Administrators — whether local or state — will have to weigh minimum staffing levels, seniority,
qualifications, and many other factors.
Giattina put it in perspective: “This big battle over the plan we just had? That was the easy part.”
Review by Senate Democrats finds more unreported luxury trips by Clarence Thomas
A report by Democrats on the Judiciary Committee found additional travel taken in 2021 by Thomas but not reported on his annual financial disclosure, including trips on private jets and a yacht trip.
Israeli strikes across Gaza kill at least 20, including five children
Israeli strikes across the Gaza Strip overnight and into Sunday killed at least 20 people, including five children, Palestinian medical officials said.
I discovered one way to fight loneliness: The Germans call it a Stammtisch
Modern life can be lonely. Some are looking to an old German tradition – of drinking and conversation – to deepen connection through regular meetups.
This Christmas I’ll be grieving. Here’s how I’ll be finding joy.
Since her husband's death, newscaster Windsor Johnston has been looking for ways to recapture joy and continue her healing journey — one that's taken her to a place she'd never expected.
On tap for the holidays: A blend of multicultural drink traditions and fond memories
For this year's All Things Considered holiday cocktail interview, we visited Providencia in Washington, D.C., a bar that brings its owners' personal stories to life.
College students get emotional about climate change. Some are finding help in class
A recent survey finds that more than half of young people aged 16-25 are highly worried about climate change. Some universities are now trying to help them navigate those emotions in class.
