South Korea halted its adoption fraud investigation. Adoptees still demand the truth

SEOUL, South Korea — South Korea’s government investigation into human rights violations in past international adoptions, which led to a landmark admission of government responsibility in March, has ground to a halt.

Adoptees and advocates are blaming the politicization and lack of understanding within the country’s Truth and Reconciliation Commission, the government body leading the investigation.

South Korea is one of the leading countries that sends children abroad for adoption. According to official data, nearly 170,000 babies have been adopted from South Korea since 1955, while experts suspect the actual number is higher. Sixty-five percent of them went to the United States.

The investigation began in 2022 at the petition of 367 South Korean adoptees from 11 countries, including the U.S., who said they were falsely registered as orphans to be put up for adoption. In an interim report in March, the bipartisan Truth and Reconciliation Commission found that in 56 cases, adoption agencies falsified or obscured documents in a process facilitated by the government.

But commissioners were divided over the very problem that prompted the adoptees’ petition: a lack of accurate documentation.

And last month, the commission decided to put the remaining 311 cases on hold, citing differences of opinion among commissioners and shortage of time. The current term for investigation ends in late May.

Minutes from the April meeting show four commission members and chairwoman Park Sun Young argued over whether adoptees needed clear evidence their identities had been intentionally falsified to be recognized as victims.

They deferred 42 other cases that were presented for review at the meeting, saying those cases lack such evidence.

The commission’s other four members said the lack of accurate documents was in itself a human rights violation and proof of government negligence.

Reverend Kim Do Hyun, president of KoRoot, a civic organization for Korean adoptees abroad, says people who lack documents are the victims of a bigger rights violation. Kim has advocated for South Korean adoptees and helped them find their roots for more than 20 years.

“The intention to destroy children’s right to origin was deeply embedded in the practice of creating orphan registrations,” Kim says.

The commission found that adoption agencies sent away babies as “abandoned children” when they in fact they were missing children or had parents. The South Korean government gave the agencies a free hand, through legislation and neglect, to collect adoption fees and donations in what the commission called a “child trade.”

Jonggeun Song, born in 1979 and adopted in the Netherlands at age 4, stages a one-person protest in front of the Korea Child Rights Protection Agency in Seoul, South Korea, on April 1. He holds a sign that reads, ''Forged Documents, Broken Lives, Release the Records.'' He calls for the disclosure of overseas adoption records and an end to international adoptions.
Jonggeun Song, born in 1979 and adopted in the Netherlands at age 4, stages a one-person protest in front of the Korea Child Rights Protection Agency in Seoul, South Korea, on April 1. He holds a sign that reads, ”Forged Documents, Broken Lives, Release the Records.” He calls for the disclosure of overseas adoption records and an end to international adoptions. (Chris Jung | NurPhoto via Getty Images)

Adoptees may face long odds in search of their origins

Studies have found that the orphan status of an overwhelming majority of South Korean adoptees was fabricated.

Because documents about their origin are nonexistent or falsified, adoptees often run into a dead end when trying to find their birth family.

Rev. Kim says it’s contradictory for the commission to recognize widespread document falsification and at the same time insist on the evidence to prove it.

Adoptees who petitioned for the investigation have hoped the commission would help them trace their roots and validate their long struggle with the adoption agencies and the South Korean government child welfare organization.

“The [Truth and Reconciliation Commission] is actually the only way for adoptees to have their cases investigated and thoroughly reviewed,” says Peter Møller, a South Korean adoptee from Denmark. He is a co-founder of the Danish Korean Rights Group, which led the petition effort.

But contrary to their wish, Møller says, “The 311 cases, they have been taken hostage, my cases included, in a domestic political fight.”

Politics bogs down the quest for truth and reconciliation

Former President Yoon Suk Yeol appointed controversial figures to head the organization. He nominated its chair, Park, just days after declaring martial law, which led to the president’s impeachment.

And Park drew objections from some staffers, civic society and victims of state violence. Citing favorable remarks she has made about the 1961 military coup and dictator Chun Doo-hwan, they said Park was unfit to lead an organization whose mission contributes to national unity by clarifying truths about state violence and government-involved human rights abuse.

Møller says Park and some commissioners may be politically motivated to shy away from accusing past conservative governments for wrongdoings, as a majority of international adoptions took place under military dictatorships in the 1970s and 1980s.

He regrets that the issue of adoptees’ basic human rights was “pulled down to a level where it is about political opinions.”

The current commission is set to close in November. For the suspended investigation to resume, a new term for the commission needs to be approved by parliament. Several bills aimed at expanding its mandate and strengthening its transparency and accountability have been filed, mostly by opposition lawmakers.

Møller says he wishes to see the commission “go back to what it was actually meant to be — this lighthouse, independent, nonpolitical lighthouse for truth and reconciliation.”

 

Palestinians say at least five people killed by Israeli gunfire near Gaza aid centers

Palestinian health officials and witnesses say at least five people were killed and others were wounded by Israeli fire as they headed to two aid distribution points in the Gaza Strip.

India (and its kids) are out to conquer the world of chess

Chess is seeing a global resurgence, sparked by The Queen's Gambit and the pandemic impact on leisure time. India is an emerging power player, with 85 grandmasters and intense chess schools for youth.

Colombian Presidential hopeful shot at Bogotá rally

A Colombian Presidential hopeful in critical condition after being shot during a campaign rally in Bogotá on Saturday. The assassination attempt is having a chilling effect in Colombia where security has been backsliding recently.

How a network of women in Latin America transformed safe, self-managed abortions

An underground network of feminists and activists developed new models of care for abortion that eventually helped legalize abortion in countries across Latin America.

NPR readers share stories of love and adversity in honor of Loving Day

June 12th is Loving Day, a holiday that commemorates the Loving v. Virginia case, which allowed interracial marriage in all parts of the U.S. NPR readers share how the case changed their lives.

Chile’s Indigenous fishermen say the salmon industry threatens their way of life

Salmon farming is big business in Chile, and the U.S. is one of its largest markets. Yet the fish are not native, and fishermen say salmon are damaging ecosystems and an Indigenous way of life.

More Front Page Coverage