FTC accuses AI search engine of ‘rampant consumer deception’
A search engine powered by artificial intelligence known as Pearl promotes itself as a distinctive service. It offers up answers generated by a large language model then a human gets involved for follow-up questions and fact checking.
There’s just one problem, according to a lawsuit filed by the Federal Trade Commission on Tuesday: the company’s offerings are allegedly a ploy to lock consumers into recurring charges they don’t want, a scheme that ensnared hundreds of thousands of people and that federal regulators are calling “rampant consumer deception.”
Here’s how federal investigators say it worked. Someone browsing the web clicks on an ad related to their online search and arrives on one of a host of landing pages the company operates. Some of the domains include JustAnswer.com, AskWomensHealth.com, AskALawyer.com, Pearl.com and hundreds of others.
Then an assistant chatbot, known as Pearl, asks further questions about the search before sending the user a form to join the company’s question-and-answer service for either $1 or $5. Once credit card information is handed over, the company starts milking consumers, according to the federal complaint.
“JustAnswer charges consumers both the $1 or $5 join fee and a significantly higher monthly subscription fee immediately at sign-up,” according to the suit by federal regulators, which began investigating the company in 2022.
The unwanted monthly fees, which can be as high as $79, continue every month until consumers cancel — something that is revealed in fine print above a large orange button that says: “Confirm now.”
According to federal investigators, this process duped hundreds of thousands of consumers, which the suit says led to a flood of complaints describing the company’s “scammy” behavior.
The company’s CEO Andy Kurtzig was aware of the consumer deception and refused to make any changes, according to the suit.
In a statement, a JustAnswer spokesperson said it is “disappointed” with the lawsuit after having engaged with the FTC for nearly three years.
“We clearly publish our pricing and model upfront, and make cancelling simple and convenient through multiple channels, including a 24/7 toll-free number, live chat, email and with one click on the web,” said JustAnswer spokesman Ashe Reardon.
The suit alleges JustAnswer has violated federal consumer protection laws and seeks an injunction against the company.
JustAnswer has about 700 employees and has raised around $50 million, according to market intelligence firm PitchBook.
The alleged techniques are an example of what’s known as “dark patterns.” That’s the technical term used to describe companies tricking consumers into signing up for services and maintaining subscriptions.
Former FTC Chair Lina Khan, whose investigators started the probe into JustAnswer, railed against such corporate behavior. She brought similar actions against major tech firms, including Amazon, which the FTC said had deployed dark patterns to trick consumers into auto-renewing their Amazon Prime subscriptions.
Lior Strahilevitz at the University of Chicago Law School who studies dark patterns said the FTC’s case highlights the age-old issue of missing the fine print before a purchase, something that continues to be prevalent online.
“The FTC and state attorneys general sue companies that employ unlawful dark patterns pretty frequently,” Strahilevitz said. “Yet these dark patterns can be a really profitable way of ripping off consumers because some consumers won’t notice the charges or won’t seek refunds promptly.”
Republicans say Clintons risk contempt of Congress for not testifying on Epstein
House Republicans are seeking testimony as part of their investigation into convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein. The Clintons say they've already provided in writing what little they know.
‘My role was making movies that mattered,’ says Jodie Foster, as ‘Taxi Driver’ turns 50
Foster was just 12 years old when she starred in the 1976 film. "What luck to have been part of that, our golden age of cinema in the '70s," she says. Her latest film is Vie Privée (A Private Life).
Supreme Court appears likely to uphold state bans on transgender athletes
To date, 27 states have enacted laws barring transgender participation in sports.
Keep an eye out for these new books from big names in January
The new year begins with a host of promising titles from George Saunders, Julian Barnes, Jennette McCurdy, Karl Ove Knausgaard and more. Here's a look ahead at what's publishing this month.
Want to play a Tiny Desk concert? The 2026 Contest is now open for entries
The 2026 Tiny Desk Contest, our annual search for the next great undiscovered artist, is now officially open for entries.
Scott Adams, the controversial cartoonist behind ‘Dilbert,’ dies at 68
Adams announced in May that he was dying of metastatic prostate cancer. Thousands of newspapers carried his strip satirizing office culture from the '90s until a controversy in 2023.
