Exhuming the past: ex-Colombian soldiers help recover victims of their own crimes
NEIVA, Colombia – As a government task force digs up mass graves in the search for civilians illegally executed during Colombia’s guerrilla conflict, they are getting some hands-on help from the perpetrators of these war crimes.
In a first for Colombia three former army soldiers, wearing white protective suits and armed with trowels and buckets, spent 10 days alongside forensic experts excavating dirt, removing bones and bits of clothing, and bagging up the remains of people killed during the war.
“These were atrocities that never should have happened,” said one of the soldiers during a mid-day break in the exhumations at a cemetery in the central Colombian city of Neiva.
The soldier, a former lieutenant colonel, asked to be identified only by his first name, Mario, for fear of reprisals. He admitted that during the mid-2000s soldiers under his command shot dead 63 civilians and reported them as guerrillas killed in action.
Mario and other ex-soldiers taking part in the exhumations have struck a deal with Colombia’s war crimes tribunal, The court, which is also investigating atrocities by the guerrillas, was set up under a 2016 peace treaty that ended much of the fighting.
Accused former combatants who refuse to cooperate face up to 20 years behind bars. But those who confess and make reparations – by providing information on how and why the murders took place and where the dead may be buried, performing social work, and apologizing to relatives of the victims – can avoid prison. Instead, they will receive sentences of five to eight years of what the court calls “restricted liberties” but has yet to define.
The former soldiers began assisting in the exhumations in Neiva last month and will continue in cemeteries around the country where most of the victims are thought to be buried.


“I think the message is very important because it’s the first time in Colombia that the criminals are looking for the victims in the cemeteries,” said Judge Alejandro Ramelli Arteaga, President of the war crimes tribunal, formally known as the Special Jurisdiction for Peace (JEP).
Drawing parallels to the Vietnam War, Mario says that Colombian officers like himself came under fierce pressure from the top brass to run up the body count. Failure could derail their careers while complying could lead to promotions, extra vacation time, and other perks.
But the policy led to massive abuses as soldiers rounded up farmers, unemployed men, and even teenagers. Then, the detainees were executed, dressed in rebel uniforms, and reported as combat kills with many buried in anonymous graves in cemeteries.
“In their eagerness to show results, soldiers grabbed innocent people and killed them,” Mario told NPR. Asked about his own reaction to the atrocities committed by troops he commanded, he replied: “It became so widespread that it seemed almost normal.”


The war crimes tribunal found that the army illegally killed more than 6,400 civilians between 2002 and 2008, a period in which the U.S.-backed Colombian military carried out massive offensive against the rebels. The executions, widely known as “false positives,” , remain a huge stain on the army’s reputation.
“It was certainly one of the most – if not the most – atrocious crimes committed during the armed conflict in Colombia,” Juanita Goebertus, a former Colombian congresswoman who took part in the peace negotiations with the guerrillas and now heads the Americas Division of Human Rights Watch, told NPR.
Now, former soldiers helping with the exhumations are getting a stark look at the damage they’ve done. In Neiva, they spent up to 10 hours per day in the tropical sun getting their hands dirty in the cemetery soil as they assisted the forensic experts. But their efforts also serve as a kind of therapy as they try to make amends.
After using a hammer and chisel to crack open a crypt holding the remains of a war victim, one former soldier, who asked to remain anonymous, said: “This is helping me to get my life together.”
Complicating these efforts is the fact that many of the dead were simply dumped into hastily dug mass graves with no identification. Diego Sevilla, who heads the government forensic team in Neiva, points to a site in the cemetery that was thought to hold the remains of six people. But his team found 12 skulls meaning that at least 12 people are buried there.
“The bodies are all mixed up,” Sevilla says.


Relatives of the victims have been closely monitoring the exhumations hoping for information about their loved ones. They include Yolanda Rocha, who said her 15-year-old brother was one of the “false positives” and may be buried here. She talked to some of the ex-soldiers, who expressed deep regret.
“It was very difficult,” Rocha said of those encounters. “You want the truth but you it’s like opening up an old wound.”
Similar exhumations – with help from ex-soldiers – will soon start in other Colombian cemeteries. But after 10 days in Neiva, the forensic team wrapped up the first phase of its work by holding a ceremony to honor the dead.
Sevilla, the team leader, recited a poem. Others solemnly place flowers atop the bags of remains. Finally, Mario, the former army officer whose men killed 63 civilians, stepped forward.
“Let’s hope this never happens again,” he said, “because the pain this has caused is immense.”

(Nathalia Angarita for NPR)
Transcript:
AILSA CHANG, HOST:
In Colombia, former army soldiers accused of atrocities during the country’s guerrilla war are trying to make amends. In fact, some are helping to locate and dig up the remains of innocent civilians executed by the Colombian military. John Otis reports.
(SOUNDBITE OF TOOLS DIGGING)
UNIDENTIFIED PERSON #1: (Non-English language spoken).
JOHN OTIS, BYLINE: In this cemetery in the Colombian city of Neiva, workers are excavating a grave thought to hold the remains of six people. The diggers include forensic experts as well as three former soldiers.
MARIO: (Speaking Spanish).
UNIDENTIFIED PERSON #2: (Speaking Spanish).
MARIO: (Speaking Spanish).
UNIDENTIFIED PERSON #2: (Speaking Spanish).
OTIS: One of them is Mario, a former lieutenant colonel who asked to be identified only by his first name for fear of reprisals. Mario was deputy commander of a nearby army base in the early 2000s when the guerrilla war was raging.
MARIO: (Speaking Spanish).
OTIS: Back then, Mario tells me, he and other officers came under fierce pressure from the top brass to run up the body count. Failure could derail their careers, while reporting more rebels killed in combat could mean promotions. But the policy led to massive abuses, as soldiers rounded up farmers, day laborers and unemployed teenagers, killed them and reported them as combat deaths.
MARIO: (Speaking Spanish).
OTIS: Mario says that troops under his command were responsible for 63 such homicides.
MARIO: (Speaking Spanish).
OTIS: “It got totally out of control,” Mario admits. “These were atrocities that never should have happened.”
UNIDENTIFIED PERSON #3: (Speaking Spanish).
OTIS: Government investigators determined that during the war, soldiers executed more than 6,400 civilians and presented them as combat kills. Juanita Goebertus heads the Americas Division of Human Rights Watch.
JUANITA GOEBERTUS: It was certainly one of the most, if not the most, atrocious crime committed during the armed conflict in Colombia.
OTIS: Now, however, Mario and other former soldiers are trying to atone for their crimes in exchange for leniency from a special court. Colombia’s war crimes tribunal, which is also investigating atrocities by the guerrillas, was set up under a 2016 peace treaty that ended much of the fighting.
ALEJANDRO RAMELLI: (Speaking Spanish).
OTIS: Tribunal president Alejandro Ramelli tells NPR that ex-soldiers can avoid prison by telling the truth about the illegal executions, apologizing to relatives of the dead and providing information on where they might be buried. He says the former soldiers are also getting a stark look at the damage they’ve done by taking part in the exhumations.
RAMELLI: I think the message is very important because it’s the first time in Colombia that the criminals are looking for the victims in the cemeteries.
(SOUNDBITE OF HAMMERING)
OTIS: Finding and identifying the dead is extremely difficult. Many were simply dumped in hastily dug mass graves, says Diego Sevilla, who heads the government forensic team in Neiva.
DIEGO SEVILLA: (Speaking Spanish).
OTIS: An example of the chaos is the grave site that was thought to hold the remains of six people. However, Sevilla’s team has found 12 skulls, meaning that at least 12 people are buried there.
YOLANDA ROCHA: (Speaking Spanish).
OTIS: All along, relatives of the victims have been closely monitoring the exhumations. Among them is Yolanda Rocha.
ROCHA: (Speaking Spanish).
OTIS: She says her 15-year-old brother was executed by troops, then dressed up as a guerrilla, and that he might be buried here in the cemetery. She’s talked to some of the soldiers who expressed deep regret for killing so many innocents like her brother.
ROCHA: (Speaking Spanish).
OTIS: “It was very difficult,” Rocha says. “You want the truth, but it’s like opening up an old wound.”
Similar exhumations with help from ex-soldiers will soon start in other Colombian cemeteries. But after 10 days in Neiva, the forensic team here is wrapping up its work.
(SOUNDBITE OF TAPING UP BAGS)
OTIS: Now they’re bagging up remains and preparing them for storage so they can eventually be delivered to relatives of the deceased.
Then the team holds a ceremony to honor the dead.
SEVILLA: (Speaking Spanish).
OTIS: Some team members recite poetry. Others solemnly place flowers atop the bags of remains. Finally, Mario, the former army officer whose men killed 63 civilians, steps forward.
MARIO: (Speaking Spanish).
OTIS: “Let’s hope this never happens again,” he says, “because the pain this has caused is immense.”
For NPR News, I’m John Otis in Neiva, Colombia.
Flood risk is widespread in the U.S. Few people have insurance for it
Climate change is increasing the risk of dangerous floods. But people often balk at the cost of flood insurance, especially since many doubt they need protection.
With social prescribing, hanging out, movement and arts are doctor’s order
Doctors are writing "social prescriptions" to get people engaged with nature, art, movement and volunteering. Research shows it can help with mental health, chronic disease and dementia.
I went on a date with my AI dream guy. Then I cried over shrimp
It started as a one-off dinner with a chatbot — a night of shrimp, sarcasm — then veered into something unsettlingly human.
By land and by sea, these new nonfiction books will carry you away
Helen Whybrow's memoir, The Salt Stones, is a closely-observed account of her life as a shepherd. In A Marriage at Sea, Sophie Elmhirst tells the true story of a couple adrift on a rubber raft.
When does a conservative lawmaker become moderate? After they disagree with Trump
Congressional Republicans have become more aligned with President Trump since he first took office. That makes even a single vote against him a "moderate" stance, even for staunch conservatives.
A lawsuit against Tesla and its driver-assistance technology goes to trial in Florida
The case, which stems from a deadly crash in 2019, raises broader questions about the safety of Tesla's driver-assistance systems, and whether the company has exaggerated their capabilities.