Alabama Immigration Law Settlement
Civil and immigration rights groups in Alabama are cheering after the state agreed Tuesday to settle three lawsuits challenging HB 56, the state’s controversial illegal immigration law. The move caps two years of legal battles and comes after the U.S. Supreme Court denied Alabama’s appeal to restore parts of the law.
Alabama’s illegal immigration law was known as the toughest in the nation. Previous court rulings had already temporarily blocked many provisions of the law, and, if this agreement is approved in federal court, the law will have permanently lost some teeth.
“You need not be an undocumented immigrant to see this resolution of the lawsuit as a very positive step for all Alabamians,” said Cecillia Wang of the American Civil Liberties Union, one of the groups that sued over the law. “There are so many civil rights violations that would flow from this sort of state anti-immigrant law that it’s truly a victory.”
The Alabama law included a wide variety of provisions critics say were designed as “self-deportation policies” for undocumented immigrants. These ranged from criminalizing the solicitation of work to making it a crime to provide transportation to any undocumented individual.
It also included provisions unique to Alabama, including voiding contracts if one of the parties involved was an undocumented immigrant, and requiring public schools to check the immigration status of newly-enrolled students.
Since many undocumented people have children who are U.S. citizens, “the prospect of verifying and asking questions about immigration status in the school setting was an extreme deterrent to these children trying to access an education,” said Kristi Graunke, an attorney at the Southern Poverty Law Center, another group involved with the challenges to HB 56.
Since the the law went into effect, Graunke says the SPLC has also seen undocumented immigrants unable to establish utility service and suffering from wage theft.
The proposed settlement agreement also addresses HB 56’s show-me-your-papers provisions.
“The state has agreed with the plaintiffs in these cases that the show me your papers provisions do not authorize any police officer or sheriff’s deputy in the state of Alabama to detain people on suspicions of immigration violations,” said Wang. She believes the repercussions will be wide-reaching in Alabama.
“This is a really significant victory because the Attorney General’s acknowledgement that any such detention would violate the Constitution is going to be key in protecting communities around the state,” Wang said.
Reaction from Alabama officials was muted. In a statement, Alabama House of Representatives majority leader Micky Hammon, one of the original sponsors of the law, said the settlement was a “great victory.”
That’s because much of the law is still intact. One element the settlement didn’t address is a provision blocking undocumented students from attending public colleges and universities. Victor Cuicahua is an undocumented student at the University of Alabama in Tuscaloosa. He found the settlement disappointing.
“I thought of all the other undocumented kids that I’ve met that had wanted to go to university, but were unable to do so. And I thought, with this settlement, a lot of the doors for them in Alabama are closed,” said Cuicahua.
A federal judge is expected to rule on the settlement in the next few weeks.
~ Rachel Osier Lindley, October 30, 2013
Electric vehicles had a bumpy road in 2025 — and one pleasant surprise
A suite of pro-EV federal policies have been reversed. Well-known vehicles have been discontinued. Sales plummeted. But interest is holding steady.
A ‘very aesthetic person,’ President Trump says being a builder is his second job
President Trump was a builder before he took office, but he has continued it as a hobby in the White House.
Teens are having disturbing interactions with chatbots. Here’s how to lower the risks
Teen use of AI chat bots is growing, and psychologists worry it's affecting their social development and mental health. Here's what parents should know to help kids use the technology safely.
Why do so many people ring in the new year on Jan. 1?
Much of the world follows the Gregorian calendar, named after Pope Gregory XIII, who put the finishing touches on a Roman system that integrated ideas from other cultures.
Pipe bomb suspect told FBI he targeted U.S. political parties, memo says
The man accused of placing two pipe bombs in Washington on the eve of Jan. 6, 2021 told investigators someone needed to "speak up" for people who believed the 2020 election was stolen, prosecutors said Sunday.
Chinese military stages drills around Taiwan to warn ‘external forces’
The drills came after Beijing expressed anger at U.S. arms sales, and a statement by Japan's prime minister saying its military could get involved if China were to take action against Taiwan.
