- AL Reading Service
Touting the federal government’s response to the novel coronavirus, President Trump took something of a victory lap on Thursday, laying out guidelines for a phased “reopening” of the country.
Trump boasted during a coronavirus task force briefing that there would be states that could reopen “immediately” — as soon as Friday and within a “few days.” After avoiding date targets for most of the briefing, Trump declared at one point, “We’re beating the date. I set a date of May 1.”
The guidelines suggest states with a 14-day “downward trajectory” of cases can start to reopen by relaxing their levels of social distancing. But the guidance doesn’t address other crucial targets that experts say states need to consider, such as wide-spread testing.
The truth is despite the campaign-like and hopeful title of the briefing — “Opening up America Again” — there’s still a very long road ahead for the overwhelming majority of the country. Consider that the 20 states, including D.C., with the fewest coronavirus cases make up just 11% of the U.S. population.
States with the most cases and the largest populations will have to act like mini-countries. It’s going to produce a patchwork of plans that could wind up looking pretty similar to the red-blue electoral maps, and there are still lots of questions, including:
1. How do issues with testing impact governors’ ability to meet the benchmarks laid out in the guidelines?
Testing remains one of the biggest problems with containing the coronavirus and allowing places to move toward recovery. Despite Trump’s boasts, testing is still not widespread in the U.S. Not everyone who wants a test can get one. Only people with symptoms are getting them — and not all of them are — and asymptomatic people are able to spread the disease. That means no one really knows just how widespread the virus is. And without a vaccine or known treatment, there’s the risk of more outbreaks.
2. Will the reopenings give a false sense of security to rural places?
Given the lack of a vaccine — with one at least a year away — a major reason behind stay-at-home orders has been to avoid overwhelming hospitals. There are fewer than 1 million hospital beds in the United States, New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo noted Thursday, and the strain would be felt even harder in underfunded rural hospitals if outbreaks start to happen in those areas.
The guidelines suggest places that see a re-occurance go back a phase, and Trump said Thursday that if “hot spots” arise, he would “whack” them. But how? Again, there’s no vaccine or proven treatment.
3. How will employers screen and do contact tracing?
These guidelines will put more of an onus on employers to do these things, and they’re not health professionals. How is that going to work in practice? And does it create liability that a local small business owner can’t afford?
4. How will travel work between states in different phases?
States will likely get to different phases at varying rates. So, one, how much of a gap will this create between states in different phases, and, two, what about travel between those places? Until there’s a vaccine or a treatment, there’s no way to be sure there won’t be flare-ups or outbreaks that could lead to places with few cases, that may have relaxed restrictions, to see unnecessary deaths.
Worldwide total confirmed cases: 2,158,033
Total deaths: 144,221
U.S. total confirmed cases: 671,151
Confirmed U.S. deaths: 33,268
SOURCE: Johns Hopkins Coronavirus Resource Center, as of 11 p.m. ET
In case you missed it, here are other highlights from the White House coronavirus task force’s daily briefing:
1. Trump’s 180 on authority: Trump is doing an about-face with these guidelines, going from falsely claiming he has “total” authority over the states to “reopen” the country to now ceding the way forward to governors. Politically, Trump is setting up a scenario that he hopes is win-win for him — if things go well, he takes the credit; if they go wrong, he blames the governors.
2. Testing still isn’t sufficient: Trump loves comparing the U.S. to South Korea on testing. “We’ve done more than South Korea,” Trump claimed. “South Korea’s done a good job, but we’ve done more.” The U.S. has now tested more Americans when it comes to raw numbers (3.4 million versus 546,000), and it is now on par with South Korea per capita.
3. More misinformation about what the U.S. knew: Trump continued to claim that the U.S. “should have been told … a lot sooner, and people didn’t want to talk about it. People should have talked about this.” They were. Plenty of other countries and world health officials were ringing alarms for months, as Trump was playing it down.
4. The path to reopening sports: Trump said that, first, sports would likely be participants-only. In other words, just the athletes playing each other in games “made for television.” While it will be odd to see games with no fans, TV is where the money’s at. Trump then noted that fans may be reintegrated separated by two seats, for example, before getting back to packed arenas.
5. Mixed message to protesters: Asked if protesters who are against strict stay-at-home measures should listen to local officials, Trump didn’t say they should and did not criticize them. Instead, he noted that this has been a “tough process for these people” and that “they want to get back.”
“I think they’re listening,” he added. “I think they’re listening to me.”
That kind of message completely undermines local authority and could only stand to encourage more of these kinds of protests and usurping of orders from governors — when people disagree politically with the authorities.
“I call it a beautiful puzzle. You have 50 pieces, all very different, but when it’s all done, it’s a mosaic. When it’s all done, it’s going to be a, I think, a very beautiful picture.”
— Trump on the country’s likely patchwork path to reopening.
What’s It Going To Take To End The Shutdown? 5 Keys To Containing Coronavirus: There are several steps the country has to take to reopen, as NPR reported Thursday:
The virus has put a crippling strain on the nation’s hospitals, and facilities are still largely unprepared for additional spikes in coronavirus patients. Already, supply shortages have ravaged many hospitals.
On average, one model suggests, that hospitals will need to double their intensive care unit and ventilator capacity to care for the most critically ill COVID-19 patients. Experts say that better systems to separate and isolate known and suspected coronavirus cases will also be critical to containing the virus.
Long Before COVID-19, Dr. Anthony Fauci ‘Changed Medicine In America Forever’: The White House’s top immunologist on the coronavirus task force has a long, storied history in medical field.
San Francisco Ramps Up Back-To-Basics Contact Tracing To Stop COVID-19: The first city in the country to implement a stay-at-home order in the coronavirus pandemic now hopes to test all residents who may have come contact with the virus and convince them to self-quarantine for 14 days.
After 7 Months In Space, Meir Will Return To A Very Different World: If you haven’t been affected by coronavirus, you must have been in outer space or something. For astronaut Jessica Meir, that’s exactly the case. She’ll return to planet Earth Friday after seven months in space, coming home to a starkly different reality.