Class-action suit claims Otter AI secretly records private work conversations
A federal lawsuit seeking class-action status accuses Otter.ai of “deceptively and surreptitiously” recording private conversations that the tech company uses to train its popular transcription service without permission from the people using it.
The company’s AI-powered transcription service called Otter Notebook, which can do real-time transcriptions of Zoom, Google Meet and Microsoft Teams meetings, by default does not ask meeting attendees for permission to record and fails to alert participants that recordings are shared with Otter to improve its artificial intelligence systems, according to the suit filed on Friday.
The plaintiff in the suit is a man named Justin Brewer of San Jacinto, Calif., who alleges his privacy was “severely invaded” upon realizing Otter was secretly recording a confidential conversation.
The suit, filed in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, claims Otter’s covert recording violates state and federal privacy and wiretap laws. It seeks to represent others in California who have had chats unknowingly shared with Otter, which the lawyers contend Otter does to “derive financial gain.”
Neither Brewer’s legal team nor a spokesperson for Otter returned requests for comment.
In recent months, new privacy questions have dogged Otter as it has become increasingly deployed in workplaces around the world.
Some 25 million people now use its AI transcription tools, which have recorded and processed more than 1 billion meetings since the company was founded in 2016, the company says.
Users have shared horror stories on platforms such as X and Reddit about Otter’s automated recording tools backfiring.
Last year, an AI researcher and engineer said Otter had recorded a Zoom meeting with investors, then shared with him a transcription of the chat including “intimate, confidential details” about a business discussed after he had left the meeting. Those portions of the conversation ended up killing a deal, The Washington Post reported.
Politico’s China correspondent has written about interviewing a Uyghur human rights activist using Otter and realizing that the company shares user data with third parties, raising fears over the possibility that the Chinese government could attempt to access raw transcriptions of conversations with dissidents. Otter has said it does not share any data with foreign governments or law enforcement agencies.
On Reddit, users have complained about Otter joining meetings automatically when the service is linked to workplace calendars and recording chats without consent.
It’s a phenomenon also highlighted by the lawsuit. If someone has an Otter account and joins a virtual meeting, the software will typically ask the meeting’s host for permission to record, but it does not by default ask all the other participants.
“In fact, if the meeting host is an Otter accountholder who has integrated their relevant Google Meet, Zoom, or Microsoft Teams accounts with Otter, an Otter Notetaker may join the meeting without obtaining the affirmative consent from any meeting participant, including the host,” the lawsuit alleges. “What Otter has done is use its Otter Notetaker meeting assistant to record, transcribe, and utilize the contents of conversations without the Class members’ informed consent.”
Otter claims that before the audio of meetings is fed into its machine learning systems to help improve an AI speech recognition feature, it is “de-identified,” a method by which data can be anonymized.
Yet the suit filed on Friday raises concerns about Otter’s ability to do this effectively, saying the company provides no public explanation of its “de-identifying” process.
“Upon information and belief, Otter’s deidentification process does not remove confidential information or guarantee speaker anonymity,” the lawsuit argues.
Mentally ill people are stuck in jail because they can’t get treatment. Here’s what’s to know
Hundreds of people across Alabama await a spot in the state’s increasingly limited facilities, despite a consent decree requiring the state to address delays in providing care for people who are charged with crimes but deemed too mentally ill to stand trial. But seven years since the federal agreement, the problem has only worsened.
Ivey appoints Will Parker to Alabama Supreme Court
Parker fills the court seat vacated by Bill Lewis who was tapped by President Donald Trump for a federal judgeship. The U.S. Senate last month confirmed Lewis as a U.S. district judge.
How Alabama Power kept bills up and opposition out to become one of the most powerful utilities in the country
In one of the poorest states in America, the local utility earns massive profits producing dirty energy with almost no pushback from state regulators.
No more Elmo? APT could cut ties with PBS
The board that oversees Alabama Public Television is considering disaffiliating from PBS, ending a 55-year relationship.
Nonprofit erases millions in medical debt across Gulf South, says it’s ‘Band-Aid’ for real issue
Undue Medical Debt has paid off more than $299 million in medical debts in Alabama. Now, the nonprofit warns that the issue could soon get worse.
Roy Wood Jr. on his father, his son and his new book
Actor, comedian and writer Roy Wood Jr. is out with a new book -- "The Man of Many Fathers: Life Lessons Disguised as a Memoir." He writes about his experience growing up in Birmingham, losing his dad as a teenager and all the lessons he learned from various father figures throughout his career.
