Alabama Says its $900 Million Prisons Plan Can Help Fix Mental Health Crisis. Some Disagree.

Mary Scott Hodgin, WBHM

A DOJ report released today alleges that conditions in the state’s male prisons violate the Eighth Amendment of the US Constitution.

Alabama’s prisons are severely overcrowded and understaffed. And in recent years, there’s been what some have called a suicide epidemic among inmates. As the state Department of Corrections continues to grapple with a federal lawsuit over mental health care, officials say they have a plan: they want to build three big regional prisons for men. But not everyone agrees that’s the best solution.

Kilby Correctional Facility, just outside of Montgomery, looks like a group of warehouse-style buildings surrounded by a tall barbed wire fence. Inside, inmates have just finished lunch. The hallways are loud and sounds echo off the walls. Warden Leon Bolling leads the way to the mental health crisis area. He says this area is for prisoners at risk of suicide.

“Everything is supposed to try to be free from person being able to do something to harm themselves,” Bolling says.

Inmates in these mental health crisis units often stay in their cells alone all day. They are constantly monitored by staff, according to prison officials. But some say that’s not enough.

An example of a mental health crisis cell. These units are for inmates on suicide-watch.
Mary Scott Hodgin,WBHM

An example of a mental health crisis cell. These units are for inmates on suicide-watch.

Suicide is a problem in Alabama’s prisons. In the past fifteen months, fourteen inmates have died by suicide. Advocacy groups say that amounts to one of the highest suicide rates in the nation. In 2017, a federal judge said mental health care in state prisons was “horrendously inadequate.” The Department of Corrections is under court order to hire more staff and improve treatment. But this is a challenge, according to Jeff Dunn, commissioner of the DOC.

“Mental health professionals in general across the state and across the country are hard to come by,” Dunn says, “and asking folks to come and work in the prison environment makes it even more difficult. And let’s be frank, the prison system is not the ideal environment to seek mental health treatment.”

It’s not just mental health care workers. Dunn says it’s difficult to get anyone to work in state prisons. The system is significantly understaffed and overcrowded. Correctional officers often work overtime and hundreds of inmates sleep side by side in large dormitories. It is one of the most violent prison systems in the country. The buildings are old and in need of maintenance. Recently, Commissioner Dunn and Gov. Kay Ivey announced a plan to address several of these issues. They want to close about a dozen male prisons and replace them with three regional prisons, bigger buildings that would house more inmates.

“We’ve got to … get to a better place in the infrastructure,” Dunn says, “if we ever have hope of changing this system and reforming it the way we want to reform it.”

He says one of the new prisons would be specifically for inmates with severe mental health needs. That facility would also provide more advanced medical services. The idea is to streamline resources in one location. But not everyone agrees consolidating prisons is the answer. Maria Morris, a lawyer with the Southern Poverty Law Center, is one of the plaintiffs in an ongoing federal lawsuit with the DOC about mental healthcare.

“The prison buildings are atrocious,” Morris says. “I don’t disagree. But they (DOC) need to be thinking through what has to be the priority.”

She says problems like suicide and violence in state prisons are the result of bad management and understaffing – something new buildings won’t fix. Morris also says bigger prisons can be harder to manage.

David Wise, a retired warden who spent 28 years working for the DOC, agrees. He says staffers at prisons that would close under the new plan might not move to where the regional prisons are. Wise says the focus should be on keeping employees.

“That would be my goal, is to get good people,” he says. “You can have all these pretty buildings, all these pretty cameras, all you want, it’s not gonna solve the part of human interaction. Prison takes human interaction to keep control.”

Commissioner Dunn says they haven’t yet decided where the new prisons will be built, but they want the location to be most convenient for employees. Dunn recently requested an extra $31 million in the state budget to increase salaries and hire 500 more correctional officers. He says new buildings can help attract candidates, including mental health care professionals.

“We believe that addressing the infrastructure piece also will help with staff morale, will help with staff effectiveness, will create a better working environment,” Dunn says.

The plan is estimated to cost around $900 million, but the DOC says that by closing several facilities, it will pay for itself. Unlike previous plans, this one might not require legislative approval if the state decides to lease the new facilities from a contractor. Officials say that will be determined later this year after they review project proposals.

More Prisons 2019 Coverage

Alabama’s New Prisons Planned For Bibb, Elmore and Escambia Counties

State officials announced the latest development in their plan to replace most existing male prisons with three regional prisons.

DOJ Finds Excessive Use of Force In Alabama’s Male Prisons

In one case, a lieutenant slammed a handcuffed prisoner on a concrete floor several times, knocking him unconscious and leaving him unable to breathe. He required hospitalization.

New Exhibit Features Artwork From Alabama Inmates

The issues around Alabama's troubled prison system are complex, but a new exhibit featuring artwork by Alabama inmates hopes to generate a different conversation.

Construction, Welding, GED: The Impact Of Prison Education

Across Alabama, state inmates are getting GED certificates, learning to fix cars, and even how to code. As Alabama faces mounting pressure to reform its prison system, many state leaders want to increase funding for these educational programs.

Study: Diversion Programs Work – When They Don’t Sabotage Participants

There are many alternatives to prison including drug courts, veterans courts and community corrections. But a new report says in many cases these alternatives hinder rather than help those they are supposed to serve.

Possible Focus on Inmate Education, DOC Oversight in 2020 Session

The 2020 legislative session begins Tuesday and prisons are at the top of the agenda. Lawmakers are likely to consider proposals presented last week by Governor Kay Ivey's Study Group on Criminal Justice Policy.

More Prisons 2019 Coverage