“Confederates in the Attic” Author On The Confederate Flag Debate

Posted by .

 ======= Old =========1476574389 
1436308739

The South has been grappling with what to do about Confederate symbols since a gunman shot 9 people at a historically black church in Charleston, South Carolina, last month. Tony Horwitz, a bestselling author and journalist, spoke with WBHM’s Will Dahlberg about Confederate imagery, memorabilia and monuments, and whether the United States should collectively push these pieces of history aside.

Horwitz is probably most known for his book Confederates in the Attic: Dispatches from the Unfinished Civil War. He also recently published Midnight Rising: John Brown and the Raid That Sparked the Civil War, in 2011. The book ties into themes of history, memory and the controversy surrounding them.

Listen to an extended version of this interview here:

History and Heritage

In the deep south, many have remaining ties with their Confederate roots. Horwitz says while there are heritage groups that push the envelope with political agendas and racial overtones, it’s important to remember that some southerners just want to remember their ancestors.

“I think we have to be careful to not paint everyone who’s interested in Confederate heritage with the same brush,” he says, “And I think perhaps there’s some of that going on in the media at the moment.”

However, Horwitz also says it isn’t always easy to separate ancestry from politics.

“No one wants to spit on their ancestors,” he says, “On the other hand, we need to find a way to remember them that doesn’t glorify the cause for which they fought.”

Memorializing the Flags and Monuments

As confederate flags come down across the South, some state officials are asking whether municipalities should move Confederate monuments out of the public realm.

Horwitz says the argument is about the perception of not what these symbols represented in the past, but what they represent now.

“The argument now is that this really shouldn’t be in the public square,” he says, “in a context in which it’s saying,’This represents all of us in our state.'”

However, Horwitz says the decisions about monuments are trickier.

“It’s easy to take down a flag,” he says, “It’s a little harder to start moving statues.”

Relocation or Removal

Much still remains to be discussed, however, about whether states should get rid of flags and monuments altogether, or just move them to new locations.

Horwitz says his only worry is that in efforts to move forward, people will erase integral parts of America’s history. He says he hopes the monuments stay where they are, but that officials add plaques to contextualize them.

“I think they can be teaching tools,” he says, “personally I’d prefer to see most of these monuments stay where they are, but that’s obviously for the people of these communities to decide for themselves.”

William Dahlberg

William Dahlberg

Deputy Director